Manchester United reviewing Carrick’s future as dismissal appears more likely
The Guardian reports that Jason Wilcox is leading the review. The BBC says a recommendation to dismiss Michael Carrick is expected, but no final decision has been made.
Manchester United are reviewing Carrick’s position. The BBC says dismissal appears increasingly likely, but no final decision has been made.
- The Guardian says Wilcox is leading the review.
- United were 18th after drawing 4-4 with Aston Villa.
- The BBC reports one league victory in 10 matches.
- The Guardian identifies Howe as Wilcox’s preferred replacement.
What's new
- The Guardian reports that Jason Wilcox is leading a review of Carrick’s position.
- The BBC reports that Wilcox and Omar Berrada are expected to recommend dismissal.
- The BBC says the board has not reached a final decision.
Manchester United were reviewing head coach Michael Carrick’s future on 9 November, following a 4-4 draw with Aston Villa at Old Trafford. The Guardian reported that director of football Jason Wilcox was overseeing the process, while the BBC said dismissal appeared increasingly likely but no final decision had been reached.12
A recommendation still to come
According to the Guardian, Wilcox is consulting chief executive Omar Berrada before making a recommendation to Sir Jim Ratcliffe, who the newspaper says controls United’s sporting policy. The BBC reported that Berrada and Wilcox were expected to recommend Carrick’s removal to Ratcliffe and the Glazer family.12
The BBC said the board remained committed to reassessing Carrick during the international break. Its report described a dismissal as increasingly likely, rather than settled. The Guardian’s account also presented the process as an ongoing decision about whether the head coach should stay.12
The review follows an earlier decision to retain Carrick in October. According to the BBC, United chose not to remove him after a 3-0 home defeat by Bournemouth, instead allowing him and the players further time before a reassessment during the November international break.2
Results under scrutiny
The Guardian reported that Carrick was given three matches to show that he and the squad could improve their start. Those fixtures produced a 2-0 defeat by Chelsea, a 3-2 victory over Roma at Old Trafford and the 4-4 home draw with Aston Villa.1
Lisandro Martínez was sent off against Chelsea, according to the Guardian. Against Villa, the newspaper reported, late goals from Joshua Zirkzee and Patrick Dorgu secured a point. The draw left United 18th, with the BBC placing them one point ahead of bottom club Crystal Palace.12
The BBC reported one United victory in 10 Premier League games and described the start as the club’s poorest in the top flight since 1986/87. Across all competitions, the Guardian put United’s record at three wins in 15 matches. Its displayed league table showed eight points.12
Defensive results also feature in the reports. According to the BBC, only Crystal Palace and Ipswich had conceded more than United’s 19 league goals. The Guardian identified repeated early concessions, including goals by Como’s Nico Paz after two minutes and Atlético Madrid’s Pablo Barrios after one minute.12
Potential replacements
The Guardian reported that Eddie Howe was Wilcox’s preferred replacement should Carrick leave. It said Howe was taking a break from football but would consider the United position. The newspaper also reported that there was no plan to add to Carrick’s coaching staff.1
The BBC reported that United had approached Howe and Julian Nagelsmann about replacing Carrick. It also said Antonio Conte was interested in the position and Mauricio Pochettino was open to moving to Old Trafford. None of those reports established who would be appointed if Carrick were dismissed.12
Why it matters
The review concerns a club sitting 18th in the Premier League, with just one win from 10 league matches, according to the BBC. United’s difficulties also extend to European competition: the BBC reported a 4-1 Champions League defeat by Como.2
Related stories
Version history
- version 1 ·
