SlovakNews

World · United Kingdom

UK Greens’ Zionism policy overshadows economic agenda as fallout grows

Former co-leader Carla Denyer warned the dispute could consume elected Greens’ time, while Zack Polanski backed the motion’s definition and European Greens demanded clarity.

Live Version: 3Sources: 4Perspectives: 4Updated:
Foto: Al Jazeera · source

What's new

  • According to The Guardian, the motion was adopted in a private vote during the Greens’ yearly Brighton gathering.
  • Former co-leader Carla Denyer warned that elected Greens could be diverted into debating and defending definitions.
  • Leader Zack Polanski said Zionism defined through what he called Palestinian displacement and genocide constituted racism.
  • The party’s newly announced economic policies received little attention amid the continuing dispute.

Fallout from the British Green Party’s decision to classify Zionism as racism continued after former co-leader Carla Denyer warned that elected Greens could be forced to spend their time debating definitions rather than acting for Palestinians. Leader Zack Polanski backed the motion’s definition, while European Greens demanded clarity and the party’s economic announcements were overshadowed.1

What the motion says

The motion describes Zionism as an ethnonationalist political project and says it should be treated like other forms of racism. It calls for a single Palestinian state across historic Palestine; according to The Guardian, the proposal specifies equal rights for all. Zionism was a driving force behind Israel’s creation in the 20th century, though Jewish organisations at times describe it as the pursuit of Jewish self-determination.1234

According to The Guardian, the result made the measure mandatory party policy for the Green Party’s English and Welsh branches. It also said Greens for Palestine promoted the motion and encouraged people outside the party to join so that it could be debated and adopted; those details have not been independently confirmed by the other dossier sources.1

Opposition inside the party

The Guardian said the measure was passed in a closed session at the Greens’ annual Brighton meeting. Four of the Greens’ five members of Parliament opposed it. Polanski missed the vote while campaigning in Holborn and St Pancras; he had sought to postpone the conference, but the party’s executive committee refused.124

Vivien Lichtenstein, who heads the Jewish Greens, said the motion would not help Palestinians and that she might leave the party. The Guardian reported that opinion among Jewish Green members was divided and that some feared disciplinary action over membership of organisations supporting Zionism. Supporters of the motion said such disciplinary action would not occur.1

The Guardian also reported that some members were consulting lawyers about a challenge under equality legislation. Adam Wagner KC told the newspaper that the challenge was likely to succeed, although no result has yet been reported.1

Condemnation from Jewish groups and Israel

The Movement for Progressive Judaism described the motion as antisemitic and said the party had made antisemitism part of its policy. The Board of Deputies, the Community Security Trust and the Jewish Leadership Council warned that it could leave the Greens as the first British party with meaningful electoral standing in living memory to adopt what they considered an apparently antisemitic platform. Chief Rabbi Ephraim Mirvis called the motion poisonous antisemitism. The Guardian cited an Institute for Jewish Policy Research report saying nearly two-thirds of British Jews identify as Zionist.1234

Israel’s foreign ministry called the policy a clear antisemitic text and said it went beyond legitimate political debate. It urged all British parties, particularly the governing Labour Party, to reject the resolution. The Israeli government also alleged that the Greens had embraced Hamas’s goal of eliminating Israel through armed struggle.1234

Supporters point to the Gaza war

Mothin Ali, the Greens’ deputy leader, said Palestinian fatalities in the war between Israel and Hamas were important context for the vote. Polanski said Zionism, when defined through what he called the displacement and genocide of Palestinians, clearly constituted racism. He and other senior Greens said support for Palestinian rights did not conflict with support for Jewish rights.123

United Nations investigators have accused Israel of genocide in Gaza, a finding Israel rejects. Britain’s government considers the actions of Israeli settlers in the West Bank to constitute ethnic cleansing, but says the question of whether Israel’s other conduct amounts to genocide must be decided by courts. Israel rejects allegations of ethnic cleansing and genocide.234

Political position

The Green Party holds five seats in Britain’s 650-member Parliament and received 6% of the vote in the 2024 national election. It has also made gains in local and special elections. The party described itself as anti-racist, said it opposed the unlawful occupation of Palestinian and Syrian territory, and again urged the Labour government in Britain to halt every form of arms trade with Israel.1234

European backlash and internal fallout

The European Green party, an alliance of 47 parties that includes Britain’s Greens, said the motion conflicted with its support for a two-state solution. It said it would demand clarity from the British party’s leadership and parliamentary group about their official positions on Israeli and Jewish self-determination and the protection of Jewish people. Felix Banaszak, co-leader of Germany’s Alliance 90/the Greens, called the policy intolerable and unacceptable and said Israel’s right to exist must not be undermined.1

Sandy Ruthven, a longstanding Green member, left the party in response to the measure, saying it had not adequately addressed antisemitism. Ellie Chowns, an MP who voted against the measure, said the party needed to update its governance and policy-development systems without delay, fuelling discussion of its member-driven process.1

Former Green co-leader Carla Denyer warned that elected representatives could be forced to devote their time to debating and defending definitions rather than taking action for Palestinians. The Guardian reported that economic policies announced by the party received little attention after the vote, as the dispute continued to dominate its conference agenda.1

Why it matters

The dispute is consuming attention as the Greens seek an electoral breakthrough and has exposed divisions between the party’s leadership, most of its MPs and its European allies. The Guardian reported that the policy could limit the party’s broader support, while Jewish organisations warned that defining Zionism as racism could affect many British Jews.124

Videos

The Green Party's Zionism vote: A turning point for the party? · Sky News
Is Zionism racist? How the Green Party’s civil war erupted at their own conference · The Telegraph
Zack Polanski Faces Green Party Backlash Over Motion Defining Zionism as Racism · Britain Breaking
Green Party members pass ‘Zionism is racism’ motion · The Independent

Related stories

Version history

  1. version 3 · New reporting says the Brighton vote was held behind closed doors, Polanski backed the motion’s definition, Denyer warned of distraction, and the dispute overshadowed the party’s economic agenda.
  2. version 2 · European Greens challenged the binding policy, Sandy Ruthven resigned, and internal debate intensified after four of five Green MPs opposed the motion.
  3. version 1 ·