World · United States of America
Cornell Student's Lawsuit Prompts Reopening of Fraternity Rape Case
A former Cornell University student has sued the college and seven fraternity members, alleging a gang rape at a Chi Phi house in 2024; prosecutors have reopened their criminal investigation after her civil complaint painted a starkly different account of the night.
A former Cornell student's lawsuit alleging a 2024 gang rape at a fraternity house has led prosecutors to reopen a criminal investigation, amid new scrutiny of campus sexual assault rates.
- Jane Doe alleges drugging and gang rape at Chi Phi house, October 2024
- Cornell expelled and suspended several accused, closed the fraternity chapter
- DA Van Houten will present evidence to a grand jury
- Cornell survey: 35% of female undergraduates report sexual assault
- Student body president and AOC demand broader scrutiny of Cornell
What's new
- A Cornell task force survey found 35% of female undergraduates reported experiencing sexual assault while at the university
- District Attorney Matthew Van Houten said prosecutors would lay out evidence for a grand jury tasked with determining whether the seven fraternity members face indictment
- The lawsuit reportedly lists Jane Doe's age as 20 at the time of the assault and names several of the accused fraternity members, details that remain disputed in some accounts
A former Cornell University student has filed a civil lawsuit against the college, seven fraternity members and an Ithaca bar, alleging she was drugged and gang-raped at the Chi Phi fraternity house in October 2024. The filing prompted Tompkins County prosecutors to announce on September 28, 2026 that they are reopening a criminal investigation into the case.13510
The allegations
Jane Doe, identified in court papers by a pseudonym, alleges she was drugged with ketamine without her knowledge and gang-raped for seven hours at the Chi Phi fraternity house in October 2024, according to the lawsuit. She says at least five other fraternity members joined the assault after a Snapchat group message alerted them to a possible sexual encounter with her.341
Her attorney, Thomas Giuffra, said the ordeal derailed her education. Giuffra said the ordeal has forced her out of school entirely, adding that she is barely coping with what the men subjected her to.52
According to reports, the lawsuit names several accused fraternity members, including one identified as Lee, and states Jane Doe was 20 when the alleged assault occurred–an age that different news accounts describe inconsistently.934
University's response
Cornell conducted an internal Title IX investigation that opened in January 2025 and involved at least twelve hearings over several months. Of the seven fraternity members accused, two faced expulsion, while the rest were given lighter penalties, among them interim suspensions handed down in November 2024. The Chi Phi chapter remains barred from campus.759
The university has rejected claims that punishment was limited to essay-writing. Kyle Kimball, who holds the role of vice-president for university relations at Cornell, verified that the inquiry led to both expulsions and suspensions, though he pointed to federal student-privacy law as the reason the school could not release specifics on any individual student. Cornell warned that repeating the claim of minimal consequences was "irresponsible" and would "perpetuate the underreporting of sexual assault."79
A conflicting account
The Tompkins County District Attorney's office had previously determined there was insufficient evidence to bring criminal charges. According to Van Houten, that determination was grounded in a sworn statement Jane Doe gave in November 2024, in which she reportedly framed her involvement in the drug use and sexual encounter as willing and consensual, with no claim of being drugged or assaulted by multiple men.12
Van Houten said the allegations in the civil lawsuit are markedly different from that earlier account, and that her attorneys had never contacted his office to say the original statement was inaccurate. "On the contrary, Jane Doe's statement described her participation in drug use and sexual conduct as voluntary, conscious, and consensual," he said, adding that such evidence was "not enough to prosecute someone criminally."21
Reopened investigation
Following the lawsuit and what Van Houten described as public outrage fuelled by incomplete news and social media coverage, his office said it would reexamine the case and present evidence to a grand jury. "We want to reexamine whether there's additional evidence that we were not aware of in November of 2024, that exists now that would change our assessment," he said, adding that if sufficient new evidence emerges, prosecutors "will do it zealously."72
His office said it had received numerous calls, voicemails and emails from the public about the case since the lawsuit was filed on September 16, 2026 in New York County Supreme Court.10
Reactions
One of the men named in the lawsuit made only "an immature comment on Snapchat" and "did nothing else," according to the dossier.52
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez faulted the university's disciplinary approach, contending that Cornell treats a suspension as though it were grounds for deportation, while allowing those accused of rape to face nothing more than writing an essay in private.7
Wider concerns about campus culture
A university-wide survey conducted by a Cornell task force on sexual assault, established in 2025, found that 35% of female students and 8% of male students said they had been sexually assaulted at some point while enrolled. In an email accompanying the task force's March 2026 report, university president Michael Kotlikoff and provost Kavita Bala said Cornell remained committed to 'communication, education, transparency, and access to resources.'710
Eeshaan Chaudhuri, who leads Cornell's student body, pressed for a new look at how the university conducted its probe, why the district attorney initially declined to prosecute, and at fraternity culture in general. He remarked that this issue reflects a much larger question beyond Cornell itself. and added that such problems clearly cannot be resolved overnight. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez made a comparable connection to elite institutions broadly, noting that upon learning what occurred at Cornell, she observed that the men had posted about it in a group chat. That means it was normal to them.'47
Why it matters
The case has revived debate over how universities and prosecutors handle sexual assault allegations, including the gap between campus disciplinary findings and criminal prosecution.12
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 2 · Added new details on Cornell's campus sexual assault survey, the student body president's call for broader scrutiny, disputed details about Jane Doe's age, and named defendants.
- version 1 ·



