World · United States of America
Peltola wins Alaska Senate race after count marked by dispute over names
The Guardian reports that Mary Peltola has defeated incumbent Dan Sullivan, giving Democrats 56 Senate seats. BBC analysis found that votes for another Sullivan would not have erased her lead.
Listen to the story
Short version
The Guardian reports that Mary Peltola won Alaska’s Senate race, giving Democrats 56 seats.
- Peltola defeated Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan, according to the Guardian.
- BBC analysis challenged claims that similar candidate names explained her lead.
- Peltola denied knowledge of the alleged candidate-recruitment effort.
What's new
- The Guardian reported on November 18 that Peltola was declared the winner.
- Her victory gives Democrats 56 Senate seats, according to the Guardian.
- BBC ballot analysis challenged claims that confusion between two Sullivans explained the result.
Democrat Mary Peltola has won Alaska’s US Senate election against Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan, the Guardian reported on November 18 after the count ended. The result followed a prolonged count and a dispute over whether a second candidate with a similar name had confused voters.12
From a narrow threshold to victory
The BBC reported on November 17 that Peltola was leading with 49.98% of the vote, but US media had not yet projected a winner. In its November 18 report, the Guardian said she had been declared the winner after counting was completed.12
The Guardian’s figures from the stage when 99% of ballots had been counted put Peltola at 50.1% and the incumbent at 45.8%. Daniel J Sullivan Jr, the other Sullivan on the ballot, had 1.7%, while Gerald Heikes had 2.1%. Those figures were not presented as the final tally.2
According to the Guardian, Peltola’s victory makes her the first Democrat elected to represent Alaska in the Senate since 2008. It brings Democrats to 56 seats after a net gain of nine in the midterm elections, with Republicans holding 44.2
What the ballots showed
President Donald Trump claimed that the contest had been rigged and that votes cast for Daniel J Sullivan Jr were intended for the incumbent, the BBC reported. Republicans argued that the similar names could have misled voters and unsuccessfully challenged the ballot arrangement in court.1
The BBC’s analysis found that adding the two Sullivans’ votes together would still leave Peltola ahead. Among ballots placing Daniel J Sullivan Jr first, 38% contained no valid second preference. Peltola received almost twice as many second preferences as the incumbent from that group of voters.1
Those preferences matter under Alaska’s ranked-choice system. According to the BBC, when nobody receives more than half of first-choice votes, officials redistribute ballots from eliminated candidates using subsequent preferences until two candidates remain and one passes 50%. New York University constitutional law professor Richard Pildes told the BBC that confusion was unlikely to have played a significant role.1
Recruitment allegations and denials
Both outlets described New York Times reporting alleging that people connected to Peltola’s campaign sought to recruit another Sullivan to run. The BBC said it had not independently verified that reporting. Peltola denied knowing about the alleged effort, her campaign denied involvement, and Daniel J Sullivan Jr denied links to the campaign.12
The Guardian reported that Trump called for Peltola’s prosecution, Alaska’s top federal prosecutor announced criminal and civil inquiries, and the governor announced plans for a criminal investigation. Separately, election-law experts quoted by the BBC said there was no specific prohibition on candidates sharing a name or on recruiting candidates for political reasons.12
Representation in the Senate
Peltola and Minnesota senator-elect Peggy Flanagan will be the first Native American women to serve in the Senate, according to the Guardian. Peltola is scheduled to take her seat in January and will be the first Alaska Native senator. She previously won Alaska’s House seat in a 2022 special election before losing to Nick Begich in 2024.2
The Guardian reported that Peltola visited more than 50 communities during the campaign and placed Alaska Native concerns at its centre. Indigenous voters account for one in five Alaska voters, the outlet said. In her victory statement, Peltola pledged to challenge Washington’s existing arrangements and work for Alaska’s working families.2
Why it matters
For European readers following US politics, the result establishes the reported balance of power in the Senate: 56 Democratic seats and 44 Republican seats. It also marks a change in representation, with Peltola and Peggy Flanagan set to become the chamber’s first Native American women.2
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 1 ·
