World · United Kingdom, United States of America
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor granted permission to challenge police searches
The High Court is scheduled to hold a closed hearing on Oct. 8 concerning access to documents in the warrant case. Buckingham Palace says the king’s private money should not fund the challenge.
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor may proceed with his challenge to police searches. An Oct. 8 private hearing will address access to judicial-review documents.
- The challenge concerns searches at Sandringham Estate and Royal Lodge.
- Mr Justice Hilliard will preside over the private hearing.
- Thames Valley Police says its misconduct investigation continues.
- The palace says the king’s private money should not fund the case.
- Mountbatten-Windsor remains released under investigation.
What's new
- A High Court judge allowed Mountbatten-Windsor to contest the legality of Thames Valley Police's searches.
- The Oct. 8 hearing will begin in private before Mr Justice Hilliard and address police efforts to restrict access to court documents.
- Buckingham Palace says Mountbatten-Windsor should not use his annual stipend from King Charles’s private funds for the judicial review.
- The palace says his legal strategy and actions are matters for Mountbatten-Windsor and his lawyers.
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor may now ask the court to examine whether Thames Valley Police lawfully searched two homes after his February arrest. A procedural High Court hearing is due to begin in private on Oct. 8 before Mr Justice Hilliard.19
Challenge to the searches
Mountbatten-Windsor has been granted permission to pursue a High Court challenge over whether Thames Valley Police acted lawfully when searching two residences. His judicial-review claim contests warrants that the force obtained from the Central Criminal Court.1238
CBS News and The Straits Times reported that the searches covered a residence on Sandringham Estate and Royal Lodge in Windsor. CBS said a Central Criminal Court judge issued the warrants on Feb. 18 and that the Royal Lodge search lasted six days.45
A hearing is due to begin in private on Oct. 8 before Mr Justice Hilliard. It will concern Thames Valley Police’s effort to restrict public access to documents from the judicial-review proceedings. The Guardian reported that it is not known whether Mountbatten-Windsor will attend.19
Arrest and continuing investigation
Police arrested Mountbatten-Windsor in February on suspicion of misconduct in public office and later released him under investigation. NPR and CBS News reported that he was questioned for 11 hours. NPR said he was neither charged nor exonerated when released. Thames Valley Police says its investigation is continuing.1234
The arrest followed the US Justice Department’s release of millions of pages from its investigation into Epstein’s sex trafficking and connections, according to NPR. The Guardian said police detained Mountbatten-Windsor on the day he turned 66 amid claims that, as the UK’s trade envoy, he had provided Epstein with sensitive information. The precise evidentiary basis for the arrest has not been established across the dossier’s sources.12
The Straits Times reported that police were investigating allegations that Mountbatten-Windsor passed documents to Epstein while working as a trade envoy. It said he denied wrongdoing connected with Epstein and regretted the friendship. CBS News also reported that he has denied wrongdoing in his associations with Epstein, while broader reports that he previously apologised and denied wrongdoing remain disputed within the dossier.3456
CBS News reported that at least nine British police forces had confirmed they were reviewing claims arising from the Epstein files. It described the Thames Valley Police inquiry as apparently the most advanced of those investigations.4
Police and royal responses
Thames Valley Police said: “We are engaged in legal proceedings in relation to warrants previously obtained from the Central Criminal Court”. The force said further comment would be inappropriate while those proceedings remained under way.13
King Charles, Mountbatten-Windsor’s older brother, said after the arrest that “the law must take its course”. Mountbatten-Windsor had already withdrawn from official royal duties in 2019 because of his association with Epstein. The king stripped him of titles and honours last October.235
Buckingham Palace says Mountbatten-Windsor receives an annual stipend of an undisclosed amount from King Charles’s private funds, but should not use that money to pay for the judicial review. The palace says it has no role in his legal strategy and that his defence is a matter for him and his lawyers.1
NPR reported that the arrest marked the first detention of a senior British royal in nearly four centuries. Citing the Daily Telegraph, The Guardian said the case was the first time a royal-family member had contested the legality of criminal proceedings since Charles I was tried in 1649. Both historical comparisons are single-source claims within the dossier.12
Why it matters
The proceedings place police searches involving a former senior member of the British royal family before the High Court while the underlying investigation remains open. For readers in Europe, the case concerns scrutiny of police warrant powers, access to judicial-review documents and the handling of an investigation involving the king’s brother.128
Version history
- version 3 · Mountbatten-Windsor has been granted permission to pursue the warrant challenge, while new reporting details the private Oct. 8 hearing and Buckingham Palace’s opposition to using the king’s funds for the case.
- version 2 · CBS News supplied new details about the warrant and arrest dates, the searched properties, the six-day Royal Lodge operation and the wider number of police forces reviewing Epstein-file claims.
- version 1 ·