Sport · France, South Africa
France beat South Africa 21-19 in Nations Championship, outlets report
France resisted a South African comeback at the Stade de France. Manie Libbok missed a late conversion that would have brought the teams level.
Three outlets report France beating South Africa 21-19 in Paris after resisting a second-half comeback.
- SA Rugby says France led 21-7 at halftime.
- Libbok missed a conversion that would have tied the match.
- The BBC reports France have four wins from five.
- France next face Argentina; South Africa play Ireland, according to the BBC.
What's new
- BBC, the Guardian and SA Rugby report a 21-19 France victory.
- South Africa recovered from a 21-7 halftime deficit, according to SA Rugby.
- The BBC says France now have four wins from five championship matches.
France beat South Africa 21-19 at the Stade de France in Paris in a Nations Championship match reported on 13 November, according to the BBC and the Guardian, with SA Rugby subsequently reporting the same result. South Africa’s second-half recovery fell short after Manie Libbok missed a conversion that would have equalised.123
First-half advantage survives comeback
France scored three tries before the interval against one for South Africa, the BBC reported. SA Rugby put the halftime score at 21-7 and identified Cobus Reinach and Malcolm Marx as the South African try-scorers in the second-half comeback.13
The Guardian described Aaron Grandidier-Nkanang scoring in the corner and Théo Attissogbe touching down after the ball struck Kalvin Gourgues’s face. Louis Bielle-Biarrey also scored following a grubber kick from Antoine Dupont, according to its account.2
South Africa had a Kurt-Lee Arendse try ruled out for offside, both the BBC and the Guardian reported. Marx later scored from a rolling maul with seven minutes remaining, according to the Guardian, but Libbok missed the conversion that would have tied the match.12
The BBC reported that France withstood South Africa’s attempts to find a winning score during the closing 10 minutes. The Guardian’s account emphasised that France prevailed despite struggling to secure lineout possession, losing almost every scrum and being without numerous players.12
Discipline and differing accounts of Dupont’s role
Both British outlets reported a red card for South Africa’s Jasper Wiese. The BBC described a 20-minute sanction for a dangerous shoulder charge; the Guardian called the offence an illegal clearout. The Guardian also reported high-tackle yellow cards for Lood de Jager and Maxime Lucu.12
The reports differed over France’s playmaking arrangement. The BBC said injuries to Matthieu Jalibert, Romain Ntamack and Antoine Hastoy had left coach Fabien Galthie with few alternatives to selecting Dupont at number 10. The Guardian said Dupont occupied his usual position, with Lucu acting as first receiver.12
The BBC named Dupont as player of the match. South Africa coach Rassie Erasmus, quoted by the Guardian, acknowledged a tactical element to the defeat: “We weren’t just outplayed, we were out-thought”. He also questioned how a defence could prepare for the facial deflection preceding Attissogbe’s try.12
Championship implications
The BBC said the victory gave France four wins from five and strengthened their prospects of finishing first in the northern hemisphere standings, while reducing South Africa’s chances of reaching the final. SA Rugby described it as France’s second victory in 11 meetings between the teams and their first over South Africa in Paris since 2005.13
France next face Argentina on Saturday, while South Africa travel to Dublin to play Ireland, according to the BBC. The same report lists the Nations Championship final for Sunday, 29 November, at Allianz Stadium.1
Why it matters
For European readers, the result affects France’s route towards the Nations Championship final: the BBC says they are well placed to lead the northern hemisphere standings. South Africa’s next fixture against Ireland in Dublin is another European match in the remaining schedule.1
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 1 ·


