SlovakNews

Slovakia

Taraba Refuses to Quit as Coalition Ally's MPs Balk at Backing His Dismissal

Environment Minister Tomáš Taraba says he will not resign voluntarily and will wait for a parliamentary vote, while three MPs of coalition partner Party of the Countryside say they will not support his removal. SNS chairman Andrej Danko, who told Robert Fico to consider retirement, wants the dismissal on parliament's agenda on Tuesday but rules out the early elections the prime minister says Smer is ready for.

Live Version: 4Sources: 12Perspectives: 3Updated:
Foto: TASR · source

What's new

  • Taraba says he will not resign voluntarily and will wait for a dismissal vote
  • Party of the Countryside's three independent MPs refuse to vote for his dismissal, citing the coalition agreement
  • Danko says SNS will never back early elections, even if Fico proposes them
  • SNS wants Taraba's dismissal added to parliament's agenda on Tuesday at 17:00
  • Pollster Václav Hřích calls a January election unlikely and points to March or April

Slovakia's environment minister, Tomáš Taraba, said he will not step down voluntarily and will instead wait for a parliamentary vote on his fate, a day before SNS chairman Andrej Danko plans to push the dismissal onto parliament's agenda at 17:00 on Tuesday, according to Noviny.sk/TV JOJ. The junior coalition Party of the Countryside then said its three independent lawmakers would not vote to remove him, invoking a coalition agreement clause barring ministers from being dismissed with opposition votes, TASR reported. Danko, who has told Prime Minister Robert Fico to consider retirement, also declared SNS would never support early elections, even as Fico said his Smer party is prepared for a January ballot.4111

Withdrawal and presidential response

The Prime Minister's Office said Fico approached the president seeking the time and political space needed to resolve the dispute, stating that the situation created by SNS demands poses a serious risk to the parliamentary majority and the government's functioning, and that coalition partners must agree on how to keep the government stable.613

President Pellegrini agreed to Fico's request, STVR reported. SNS, however, treats the withdrawal as an unprecedented breach of the coalition agreement, according to TASR and Pravda.312

Even after the formal withdrawal, Danko kept demanding Taraba's replacement. Fico had earlier said he would take back the dismissal proposal only if SNS failed to reach an internal agreement over the minister's fate, according to Global Banking & Finance Review.8

Danko also aimed a pointed message at the prime minister himself, telling him to consider retirement and suggesting Fico no longer understands political reality. "Ak sa Robert Fico cíti, že chce ísť na dôchodok, tak myslím si, že je čas sa nad tým zamyslieť," he said, according to Noviny.sk/TV JOJ; Postoj reported the same message the day the proposal was withdrawn.411

Taraba's response

Taraba maintained there was no substantive fault or valid reason for his dismissal.6109

His position has since hardened. TASR reported that Taraba said he was shocked by SNS's stance on his dismissal, and Noviny.sk/TV JOJ reported he announced he would not resign voluntarily and would instead wait for any dismissal vote, urging Danko to choose constructive dialogue over confrontation.14

SNS ultimatum

SNS, which has pushed for months to have Taraba removed, rejected suggestions that it bears responsibility for the coalition's strain. The party gave Taraba an ultimatum to resign by September 30, as it says he had previously promised, warning it would otherwise seek his removal through a parliamentary vote, and argues his continued tenure prolongs political uncertainty.314

65

Election threat and opposition manoeuvre

Fico warned that if Danko and Taraba fail to offer assurances and instead topple the government, snap elections would follow, and insisted the blame would not fall on him. "If Danko and Taraba want to leave, then I ask them to put an end to this circus," he said.37

Opposition Progressive Slovakia leader Michal Šimečka confirmed his party submitted a motion to move a dismissal vote to immediate parliamentary deliberation, saying 33 votes back holding early elections as soon as possible; TASR reported PS planned to table the dismissal proposal on Tuesday. STVR reported that cutting the parliamentary term short would require a constitutional majority of 90 lawmakers.31

Analyst commentary

Political analyst Eduard Chmelár, writing for Pravda, said early elections cannot be ruled out but are not the most likely scenario, and suggested Fico hardened his stance because he no longer wants his government dependent on individual rebellious MPs, including Taraba.2

Chmelár argued the coalition is based on mutual dependence among its members and said, "On nie je samostatná jednotka," adding that if partners fail to agree, the only remaining extreme options are early elections or a caretaker government. He also said, "Je to vzájomne previazané a nemôžu si ako malé deti teraz vyhadzovať na oči, kto je zodpovedný."2

Coalition partners and opposition react

Hlas-SD deputy chair and Labor Minister Erik Tomáš said his party has no interest in early elections and wants Danko and Taraba to reach an agreement that preserves the government's parliamentary majority. "Ja si myslím a pevne verím v to, že sa napokon pán Danko a pán Taraba dohodnú," he said, adding that Hlas-SD still wants to push through remaining legislative priorities, according to Hospodárske noviny and TASR.61

Opposition SaS deputy Marián Viskupič accused the government of delivering instability instead of the peace and stability it had promised, saying, "Táto vláda sa už dávno nevenuje občanom, táto vláda sa venuje len a len svojim problémom." He also predicted the government would yield to what he called "extortionists" in next year's budget, which he said carries a 4.9% deficit despite the finance minister's earlier 3% target, according to Hospodárske noviny and TASR.61

Hnutie Slovensko MP Roman Mikulec said his party would back Taraba's dismissal if the proposal reaches parliament and that its leaders are coordinating with other opposition parties. Mikulec also called Fico a "traitor" and said convening the Security Council "has no purpose" while Fico sits on it, according to Aktuality.sk.5

Coalition partner refuses to supply votes

The push to oust Taraba ran into resistance from inside the coalition itself. TASR reported that the three independent MPs elected with the Party of the Countryside will not vote for his dismissal in the National Council, citing the coalition agreement's rule that ministers are not removed with opposition support. "Strana vidieka rešpektuje koaličnú zmluvu, podľa ktorej sa ministri v parlamente neodvolávajú s podporou opozície," their statement said.1

The party, led by Tourism and Sports Minister Rudolf Huliak, described itself as a firm part of the governing coalition and said it has long been dissatisfied with Taraba's results, listing unresolved problems such as an overpopulated bear population and attacks on people, zoning and national park reform, and the drawdown of EU funds. Even so, it said it respects that the environment portfolio belongs to SNS.1

Danko rules out early elections

At a Monday press conference responding to Fico's remarks, Danko rejected early elections outright, saying SNS would never vote to shorten the electoral term even if Fico himself proposed it, and argued that responsibility for any such move would rest with the Smer chairman, Noviny.sk/TV JOJ reported. He dismissed Fico's election talk as a somewhat failed joke and said the coalition agreement had become meaningless to the prime minister.4

Danko said he had exhausted all possibilities of decent negotiation within the coalition and announced SNS would try to have Taraba's dismissal added to parliament's agenda in a vote on Tuesday at 17:00, arguing that leaving the minister in place prolongs political uncertainty.4

How likely is a January vote?

Fico said in a TA3 interview that early elections could take place in January and that Smer is prepared for that scenario, adding the party could push for a shortened term together with part of the opposition, Noviny.sk/TV JOJ reported. Smer-SD's Agriculture Minister Richard Takáč indicated nothing has been ruled out, remarking, "Myslím si, že v tomto prípade môže byť každá alternatíva. Aj toto je jedna z alternatív."4

Václav Hřích, director of the AKO polling agency, said a January election is unlikely given the time needed to call one, suggesting the turn of winter and spring, or March and April, as more probable, and noted it is unclear how many coalition MPs would actually vote to shorten the term. SaS politician Alojz Hlina argued the government should serve out its full term.4

Why it matters

The fight over a single ministry has turned into a test of whether Fico's three-seat majority can hold, and the arithmetic is now working against SNS: its own coalition partner says it will not supply votes to oust Taraba, while the opposition is ready to. Fico has floated a January snap election and says Smer is prepared for one; Danko says his party will never vote to shorten the term, leaving the coalition deadlocked rather than resolved.147

Videos

R. Fico: Stačilo. Ľudia sa smejú, nechápu. Sťahujem návrh na oodvolanie Tarabu · Televízia ta3
HARABIN: FICO NEMÔŽE STIAHNUŤ NÁVRH NA ODVOLANIE TARABU podľa Ústavy SR | TVOTV · TVOTV
Dobré ráno sobota: House of cards Tomáša Tarabu · SME

Related stories

Version history

  1. version 4 · Rewritten around the newest developments: Taraba refuses to resign and awaits a parliamentary vote, the Party of the Countryside's three MPs say they will not back his dismissal, Danko rules out early elections while seeking a Tuesday vote, and earlier reports that Taraba had already left the cabinet are flagged as contested.
  2. version 3 · Added new reporting that SNS chairman Andrej Danko reportedly urged Fico to consider retirement, and that SNS itself is unsure of full party support for ousting Taraba.
  3. version 2 · Reports that Taraba actually resigned from the cabinet despite the earlier withdrawal, with Fico now floating a snap election in January and coalition partners/opposition reacting.
  4. version 1 ·