SlovakNews

World · United Kingdom, France

UK-France Migrant Returns Deal Ends Amid Scrutiny Over Scale and Treatment of Returnees

The year-long 'one in one out' pilot expired after extension talks collapsed, with new reporting showing it returned only about 1,500 people against more than 40,000 Channel arrivals and raising concerns about force used on and risks facing those sent back to France.

Live Version: 2Sources: 9Perspectives: 2Updated:
Foto: The New York Times · source

What's new

  • New reporting shows the pilot ran 423 days and returned about 1,500 people while more than 40,000 crossed the Channel by small boat in the same period
  • Officers used physical force in roughly one out of every ten cases among the 224 asylum seekers sent back to France during the year's first quarter, and returnees' injuries were recorded
  • Returnees reported being threatened by smugglers over debts, vanishing after return, and in some cases being sent back to France a second time
  • France pushed for a Europe-wide replacement scheme, which other European countries have not agreed to join

The UK-France 'one in one out' migrant returns deal lapsed on 1 October 2026 after 423 days in which roughly 1,500 people were returned to France against more than 40,000 small-boat arrivals in Britain, with new reporting detailing force used in removals, documented injuries, and criticism from campaigners and a Labour MP over the scheme's human cost.134

How the pilot worked

Then-UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron unveiled the initiative in July 2025, with the first transfer flights departing that September. The arrangement allowed Britain to detain and send back to France people who had arrived by crossing the Channel in small boats, while France, in exchange, transferred a matching number of asylum seekers who had connections to Britain. According to the Guardian, the deal ran for 423 days, from 10 July 2025 until its expiry on 1 October 2026.1234

The Straits Times reported that transfers were meant to happen within three months of arrival at the latest, and that the UK had to send someone back within two weeks of their arrival. France was not obliged to accept unaccompanied minors or people deemed security threats.5

Accounts of the pilot's intended duration differed. Agence France-Presse reported it was initially agreed to last a year and had been extended to 1 October. According to the Guardian, the agreement was originally set to end in April, but its duration was pushed back to October in order to address an expected increase in summer crossings. The South China Morning Post reported the agreement was meant to run for three years, with a clause allowing either side to end it earlier.267

Why the talks collapsed

Talks to prolong the arrangement collapsed because France was insisting on a continent-wide returns framework and was hesitant to raise the volume of people being exchanged. France was not prepared to continue the scheme alone with Britain. Nuñez asked pointedly, according to the Guardian: "Why do we have to manage this border on our own?" He said France believed any future arrangement should be between the European Union and the UK rather than a bilateral deal, though other European countries have not agreed to join such a scheme.12

French Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez recounted having informed his UK counterpart back in June that the trial program, agreed to in August 2025, was never meant to continue past 1 October 2026: "I have therefore already made it clear to my counterpart that this pilot agreement, which we signed in August 2025, was not intended to be extended beyond 1 October 2026."16

Le Monde, cited via AFP, reported that UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham urged Macron during September to preserve the arrangement, though French officials were eager to wind it down, with the paper noting "Paris was in a hurry to end the cooperation."68

The French interior ministry confirmed it was negotiating the terms of withdrawal. A ministry source said: "We are discussing the terms of withdrawal from the agreement with the British."568

UK officials said the scheme had struggled operationally, in part because of detention space constraints that made it difficult to increase removals. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood said: "What has been more operationally difficult is to scale up very large numbers of removals every week into the French system."126

Criticism over scale and treatment of returnees

Fresh Guardian coverage highlighted just how far the scheme fell short of its goals: roughly 1,500 asylum seekers were sent back to France across the entire pilot, even as over 40,000 people reached Britain by small boat in that same window – a total removals figure the paper noted was lower than the arrivals tallied in certain single weeks last month.1

According to the Guardian, physical force was applied in about one of every ten removals among the 224 asylum seekers transferred to France during the first quarter of this year, and the paper recorded both physical and psychological harm among those who had been returned. The Home Office suggested some injuries may have been self-inflicted.1

That same coverage noted that dozens of returnees made their way back to the UK, citing safety fears, that smugglers had threatened some asylum seekers over money they owed, that a considerable number were thought to have disappeared once returned, and that a handful had been deported to France more than once. The Guardian quoted one returned asylum seeker reacting to news the scheme would end: "Thank God. You gave me the best news." Another, hoping to be transferred to the UK, said: "That's good news. We simply hope that Britain doesn't end up with an even worse arrangement with a different country."1

Labour MP Bell Ribeiro-Addy accused the Home Office of "victim blaming" over its handling of injuries among returnees, according to the Guardian. The paper also noted that forcible removal is not possible to countries such as Iran, Eritrea and Sudan, from which many small-boat arrivals originate, limiting the pool of people who could be sent back under the scheme.1

Numbers, costs and deaths

French and British officials said about 1,500 people were returned to France under the deal, with a slightly smaller number transferred to Britain. The Guardian cited a comparable total of about 1,500 people returned and a similarly sized group legally transferred to Britain from France, while separately referencing an earlier figure claiming over 1,400 removals at an estimated cost of roughly £56,000 each.1679

The Guardian reported that, as of late June 2026, a total of 1,117 people with UK connections had been moved from France to Britain under the program. The same reporting said flights removing detained people would continue but were expected to end within weeks.2

According to the Guardian, 19,135 individuals made the crossing via small boat between January and 27 September, which the paper described as a 42 percent drop compared with the same stretch the year before. AFP reported a figure of 19,196 crossings for 2026 overall, also described as a 42 percent year-on-year fall, and said at least 22 people had died crossing the Channel during the year. In a separate report, the Guardian noted that small-boat crossings of the Channel dropped over 40 percent during January through May this year versus the same months last year, while cautioning that a broader decline in arrivals to Europe could account for part of that UK decrease.126

A child and two women died in a Channel crossing earlier in the week the deal expired, according to the Washington Times. AFP said three migrants, one of whom was a 10-year-old boy, lost their lives off France's coast during a crossing attempt. Separately, a French court sentenced six men to between six and ten years in prison over deaths in a November 2021 Channel tragedy, describing those responsible as "individuals driven by greed, with utter disregard for human life."69

Nuñez said data from the UN refugee agency suggested awareness of the scheme was spreading and leading some migrants to drop plans to attempt the crossing: "According to information from the UN high commissioner for refugees, word of the scheme is beginning to spread, which is prompting a number of migrants to abandon their plans to make the crossing." He also argued that France should not be left to shoulder this responsibility on its own.1

The Guardian also reported that detainees deported to France did not always remain there: some became homeless in Paris, some returned to camps around Calais and Dunkirk, and others made the crossing back to the UK.2

Reactions

A UK government source downplayed how significant the deal's expiry was, indicating they would have preferred for the arrangement to carry on. The source added that its end was not catastrophic, since the scheme had never grown large enough to serve as a genuine deterrent to people crossing to the UK in small boats.12

Mahmood recognized the program's shortcomings yet warned against assuming other options were better, arguing that viewing the pact as a long-term solution would be a serious error. She insisted that joining such a pact would not make the underlying problem disappear, despite assurances to the contrary, and separately noted that increasing the volume of removals had proven difficult in practice.12

Starmer, who announced the scheme in 2025, had said at the time: "There is no silver bullet here, but with a united effort, new tactics and a new level of intent, we can finally turn the tables."2

The Home Office acknowledged the pilot was being phased out, explaining that the UK-France program for exchanging asylum seekers for an equal number of legal migrants had stopped taking on new cases, and added that it would keep pursuing removals of small-boat arrivals wherever possible via alternative channels.16

Campaigners and at least one Labour MP criticised the scheme's human costs. Bell Ribeiro-Addy accused officials of "victim blaming" over injuries documented among returnees, while Medical Justice said it had "condemned the trauma they have documented due to the detention of this group."1

Why it matters

The end of the pilot removes one of the few bilateral mechanisms Britain and France had built since Brexit to manage Channel crossings, at a time when crossing numbers remain high and deaths continue to occur. New reporting on the scheme's small scale relative to overall arrivals, and on force used and harm documented among returnees, has intensified scrutiny of how future returns arrangements are designed. France's push for a Europe-wide replacement signals that any successor deal may depend on wider EU cooperation rather than a UK-France-only arrangement.12

Related stories

Version history

  1. version 2 · Added new Guardian reporting on the pilot's small scale versus overall Channel arrivals, documented force and injuries in removals, and criticism from NGOs and a Labour MP.
  2. version 1 ·