Science & Tech · United States of America
Apple plans tighter Mac controls as expert questions Meta’s Muse denial
Apple plans clearer Full Disk Access controls after complaints about Meta’s Muse. Meta says Messages access requires two permissions, while a security expert says disk access makes chats technically readable.
Listen to the story
Short version
Apple plans tighter Full Disk Access controls amid a dispute over whether Meta’s Muse accessed private messages without permission.
- Meta says Muse needs Full Disk Access and its Messages connector.
- Aten says Muse referenced a Messages thread without his permission.
- Security expert Patrick Wardle says disk access makes chats technically readable.
- Apple has not announced when its new controls will arrive.
Infographic
What's new
- Mac security expert Patrick Wardle questioned Meta’s denial, saying Full Disk Access makes non-root files, including chats, readable.
- Meta CTO David Singleton says Muse can read Messages only when Full Disk Access and its Messages connector are both enabled.
- Jason Aten says Muse sent an unsolicited notification referring to an Apple Messages thread he had not authorised it to read.
- Apple plans stricter macOS privacy controls intended to curb misuse of broad disk access by third-party applications.
Apple plans tighter macOS privacy controls to make broad data-access requests more explicit as questions continue over Meta’s Muse agent. Meta says Muse requires Full Disk Access and an enabled Messages connector to read Messages, but macOS security expert Patrick Wardle questioned its denial, saying Full Disk Access technically makes non-root files, including chats, readable.1245
Infographic
A broad macOS permission
Full Disk Access can give an application access to files, email, messages and browsing history. Apple said the permission largely bypasses the privacy controls that ordinarily govern access to those categories, allowing applications such as backup tools to work properly. The company said some developers use the permission in ways that can expose information without users fully understanding the extent of the access.12
Apple said the risks would increase substantially as AI agents become more capable and autonomous. Desktop agents can be given access to personal material by changing macOS settings, according to TechCrunch, creating a wider range of information that such software may be able to process.12
Apple says it will more clearly alert users when an AI agent asks for permission to view everything stored on a Mac. Its additional controls are intended to ensure that granting Full Disk Access requires very explicit user action. Apple has not described the controls in further detail or said when the update will be released.123
Dispute over Meta’s Muse
The announcement follows complaints from users who said Muse, Meta’s general-purpose AI agent, accessed messages they believed were private. Inc. writer Jason Aten alleged that Muse knew the contents of private Mac messages even though he had not granted permission to read them or enabled Full Disk Access. Meta disputes his account.1234
Aten said Muse sent an unsolicited notification suggesting a column based on an Apple Messages conversation with a co-worker and also flagged a message from an editor. He reported that the application had synchronised his Messages database as far as row 187,462 while Full Disk Access was switched off.45
Meta spokesperson Andy Stone said Muse can read Messages content only when a user grants Full Disk Access and turns on the Messages connector. Meta CTO David Singleton also described the integration as opt-in and said both permissions are required; he separately said reading Messages involves three approval steps across Muse and macOS.2345
Mac security expert Patrick Wardle questioned Singleton’s denial, arguing that Full Disk Access makes any non-root file technically readable, including chats, browsing history and browser cookies. Meta’s communications staff reiterated Singleton’s position that reading Messages through Muse depends on granting disk-wide access and enabling the app’s Messages integration. The available reporting does not establish how Muse obtained the information described by Aten or whether it accessed his Messages database without the permissions Meta says are required.45
Other reports involving agent access
TechCrunch also referred to a Wired report that a flaw in the ChatGPT Mac application could have allowed attackers to obtain sensitive information. Separately, The Next Web reported that a YouTuber said Muse had supplied his address to a Facebook Marketplace buyer; the user later said he had selected an option allowing continuing access.15
These reports concern different applications and circumstances, but each involves the permissions or information available to desktop AI software. Apple’s announced response focuses on making requests for broad Mac access more obvious and requiring explicit user action, rather than targeting a specific AI agent or developer.1234
Why it matters
Full Disk Access can put files, email, messages, browsing history and browser cookies within an application’s reach. Apple says increasingly capable and autonomous AI agents make that permission substantially riskier. Meta maintains that Muse also needs its Messages connector enabled, while Wardle’s comments highlight the broad technical access available once Full Disk Access is granted. Apple has not announced a release date.1234
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 3 · Ars Technica reports that security expert Patrick Wardle questioned Meta’s Muse denial because Full Disk Access technically makes non-root files, including chats, readable.
- version 2 · New reporting says Apple will make AI requests for access to all Mac data more obvious, while complaints about Muse have broadened beyond Jason Aten and Meta maintains that Messages access is opt-in and revocable.
- version 1 ·


