SlovakNews

Culture · France

Eiffel Tower Chief to Resign Over Exclusion of Female Staff

Patrick Branco Ruivo will step down as head of the company running the Eiffel Tower after an internal inquiry found operational failures led to female employees being removed during a Hindu delegation's visit in September.

Live Version: 4Sources: 16Perspectives: 3Updated:
Foto: The Independent · source

What's new

  • Sete revealed that its director general, Patrick Branco Ruivo, will leave his position before the year concludes, following an internal probe
  • Internal probe found operational flaws and shortcomings led female staff to be pulled from the tower's third floor
  • French authorities have opened a formal investigation into the removals, according to CBS News
  • Marine Le Pen joined Prime Minister Gabriel Attal, Yaël Braun-Pivet and other officials in condemning the exclusion of women staff
  • BAPS apologised and told the Associated Press the coordination was meant only as operational courtesy, not a gender-based request

On 29 September, the firm that manages the Eiffel Tower announced that director general Patrick Branco Ruivo would step down before year's end, following an internal review that traced the sidelining of female employees during a Hindu delegation's Paris visit to failures in how the event was handled.124

The incident

Female employees were excluded from contact with a delegation from the Bochasanwasi Akshar Purushottam Swaminarayan Sanstha (BAPS), a worldwide Hindu religious and civic organisation, during a visit to the tower. Sources said workers were instructed to avoid certain zones, with several pulled from their duties and substituted by male colleagues, while directions were also issued for women–including those employed by outside contractors–to stay out of sight.254

The Eiffel Tower Operating Company, known as Sete, said its investigation uncovered problems in the planning of the visit, which took place on 5 September, that led to the exclusion of female staff. Sete acknowledged that a request from the delegation to limit interactions with women should not have been accepted.128

Sete later specified that the affected employees had been withdrawn from the tower's third floor, and acknowledged that doing so had been a mistake.7

Eiffel Tower employees staged a walkout in protest. Diane Davoine, a representative of the staff union, said women "were asked to leave their places of work in order to place men there," adding that the treatment left employees, and women in particular, feeling humiliated. In a statement, staff said they were subjected to "workplace policies that have led to female employees being sidelined, replaced and rendered invisible because of their sex," calling this "deeply contrary to the values of equality and nondiscrimination."2314

Response and resignation

Emmanuel Gregoire, the Socialist mayor overseeing the file, ordered two separate probes into the affair, saying it was "not acceptable that such conditions can be tolerated," since they clashed with the values he said the Eiffel Tower should uphold. Ariel Weil, mayor of the Paris Centre district, called for gender equality measures and training programmes to be introduced at Sete.268

The incident drew condemnation from senior political figures across the spectrum. National Assembly President Yaël Braun-Pivet said she refused "to allow women to be compelled to step aside in order to meet the demands of foreign visitors," while Marine Le Pen, who is favored to lead the far-right ticket in next year's presidential race, declared, "in France, we will never accept the presence of women being 'limited.'" Sete also pledged to create an independent protocol unit and launch fresh training programmes aimed at promoting gender equality.172

French authorities separately opened a formal investigation into the removal of female staff, CBS News reported. Gabriel Attal, France's centre-right head of government, likewise denounced the incident, stating that in France "no culture, no belief, no worship, nothing nor anyone can come dictate to women their place."4

Weil said the coming months would allow the company "to prepare for the leadership transition under the best possible conditions." Branco Ruivo, who has led Sete since being appointed director general in November 2018, will remain in post until the end of the year, according to the company.2841

BAPS issued an apology, offering "sincere apologies to anyone who may have been hurt or inconvenienced by this situation." The organisation also said that "to the best of our knowledge, at no point was anyone prevented from accessing the Eiffel Tower," and noted that, because of the size of its delegation, the visit had been arranged jointly with the Eiffel Tower team. In a separate statement provided to the Associated Press, BAPS characterized the coordination as "undertaken purely as a matter of operational courtesy and logistics .. without inconveniencing the Tower's employees or the public," insisting the arrangement "was never, at any point, intended as a request rooted in gender," and stating it mirrored "the universal values of mutual respect and service."2178

Context

The BAPS group's presence near Paris coincided with the opening of its inaugural large-scale traditional stone temple on French soil, located in Bussy-Saint-Georges to the east of the city. BAPS is part of the Swaminarayan movement within Hinduism and has ties to Narendra Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party. The delegation that visited the Eiffel Tower numbered about 100 people. According to the Guardian, the group's spiritual leader, Mahant Swami Maharaj, observes vows that forbid contact with women, a claim reported by that outlet alone.2631

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi appeared by video link at the inauguration of the Bussy-Saint-Georges temple, calling it a "new milestone in the cultural relations between India and France," according to CBS News. CBS News further pointed to a 2021 American lawsuit alleging that BAPS exploited low-caste labourers brought from India to construct a temple in New Jersey, and reported workers' belief that two of their colleagues died from a lung illness that could have been prevented during that project–allegations BAPS has not responded to amid the present controversy.4

The Eiffel Tower, owned by the City of Paris, draws nearly seven million visitors a year. It was previously shut for six days in February 2024 when employees went on strike over maintenance concerns and pay, according to the Independent.253

Why it matters

The episode has touched on questions of gender equality and secular values that France presents as core to its national identity, prompting cross-party political criticism. For a landmark that hosts nearly seven million visitors a year and stands as a symbol of the country, the dispute over how it accommodates visiting delegations carries wider resonance for workplace practices at prominent public institutions in Europe.25

Related stories

Version history

  1. version 4 · Added Marine Le Pen's condemnation of the exclusion, corrected Ariel Weil's role to mayor of Paris Centre, and included new details on BAPS's delegation size, its BJP ties, and fuller quotes from Gregoire and BAPS.
  2. version 3 · Added detail on France's formal investigation, PM Gabriel Attal's condemnation, union representative Diane Davoine's account, BAPS's fuller AP statement calling the request operational rather than gender-based, and context on Modi's video appearance at the new BAPS temple.
  3. version 2 · Added detail that removed staff were withdrawn from the tower's third floor, Sete's acknowledgment of the mistake and plan for a protocol department, and quotes from politicians condemning the incident.
  4. version 1 ·