World · Israel, United Arab Emirates
Netanyahu orders aviation security review after alleged Flydubai attack
The review follows reports that the co-pilot attacked Captain Smit Machchhar with a cockpit crash axe and tried to bring down the aircraft. A 2024 state comptroller report found no clear division of responsibility for foreign-airline security in Israel.
Listen to the story
Short version
Netanyahu ordered a security review after the alleged Flydubai cockpit attack. Investigators have not established the co-pilot’s motive or whether he acted under direction.
- The National Security Council will appoint an examiner.
- A 2024 report found unclear foreign-airline security responsibilities.
- Passengers subdued the co-pilot after Machchhar opened the cockpit door.
- The aircraft landed safely in Saudi Arabia.
- Opposition figures demanded accountability for the security lapse.
What's new
- Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called for an examination of security measures on overseas flights arriving in Israel.
- National Security Council head Shmuel Ben Ezra was instructed to appoint an examiner.
- A 2024 state comptroller report found unclear responsibility for foreign-airline security.
- Opposition figures blamed the government and demanded accountability for the security failure.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ordered a review of security arrangements for international flights to Israel after the alleged attack aboard Flydubai flight FZ1073. His office said Shmuel Ben Ezra, who leads the National Security Council, would name a reviewer to comprehensively assess security for foreign civil aviation, while opposition figures sought accountability for the failure.8911
A struggle in the cockpit
Reports said the Omani co-pilot attacked Machchhar, seized the controls and tried to bring down the aircraft. CBS News and The Independent said the plane lost over 14,000 feet of altitude within under half a minute. The precise circumstances and motive remain under investigation.247
Machchhar said he suffered numerous wounds but fought to get up because he believed the passengers would otherwise die. Covered in blood, he opened the cockpit door, allowing passengers and others aboard to reach and restrain the co-pilot. Passenger Yaniv Hayoun said he then grabbed the controls and pulled back on them as the aircraft descended.457
Israeli passengers helped subdue the attacker. They said he asked them to kill him after he was restrained and that they remained unsure whether other crew members were involved. Shota Musayev, a passenger and doctor, treated Machchhar’s wounds and urged the crew to land.27
The flight made an emergency landing in Saudi Arabia on 30 September. Their identities had not been publicly confirmed in the reports.16
Published totals for those aboard differ. The Independent reported 182 people, Euronews listed 174 passengers and six crew members, and Middle East Eye reported 180 passengers, most of them Israeli. According to CBS News and The Independent, the aircraft dropped more than 14,000 feet in under half a minute; The New York Times put the fall at nearly 17,000 feet, though that number has been challenged.1245
Investigation and unanswered questions
The UAE is leading the investigation, with Israeli representatives participating, according to CBS News and The Hindu. Saudi authorities arrested and questioned the co-pilot after the landing; CBS later reported that he was undergoing another round of interrogation in the UAE. His motive has not been established.1234
CBS News reported that an initial Israeli inquiry assessed the incident as probably the work of a lone actor and that investigators viewed it as resembling a suicide attempt more than a conventional hijacking. It also reported that the co-pilot shouted for others to kill him after he was restrained. Netanyahu subsequently said Israeli authorities were looking into whether the co-pilot had been acting on another person's instructions, while the inquiry continued.2711
CBS identified the accused co-pilot as Hamam al Hamami, an Omani citizen who was not born in Oman. It said Oman Air monitoring showed al Hamami accessing extremist websites, and that Flydubai employed him without checking his background with Oman's government. Netanyahu said the co-pilot had undergone Islamist radical indoctrination.123
Scrutiny of pre-flight checks
Accounts of responsibility for pre-flight checks conflict. The Hindu reported that Emirati authorities supplied Israel with passenger and crew details before the flight, but Israel raised no warning. The Shin Bet said responsibility for checking lists from foreign flights lay with the Transportation Ministry, while Transport Minister Miri Regev said security agencies were responsible. The Straits Times and South China Morning Post reported that foreign-airline security oversight involved Mossad and the Shin Bet and that a 2024 state comptroller report found no clear division of responsibility.389
Critics questioned how a pilot from a country without diplomatic relations with Israel was cleared to operate the flight. The Straits Times and South China Morning Post said aviators from states considered hostile to Israel had still made repeated flights there in recent years, raising questions over the clearance granted to the Omani co-pilot.389
Netanyahu ordered a review of all security aspects involving foreign civil aviation to Israel. His office said National Security Council head Shmuel Ben Ezra would appoint an examiner. Opposition leader Yair Lapid called the review a sham investigation, former transport-ministry director-general Keren Terner blamed Regev, and Yashar party leader Gadi Eisenkot said the transport minister should resign.8911
Passengers honoured and recovery support
Netanyahu said the four passengers would light a torch representing civilian heroism at Israel’s Independence Day ceremony.57
The Jerusalem Post reported that two online fundraisers had raised more than $79,000 combined for Machchhar’s recovery. One fundraiser run by Jewish Breaking News brought in over $73,000, and another, set up by Tal Dooreck, received more than $6,000.7
Why it matters
The review shifts attention from the passengers’ intervention to how the co-pilot was cleared to operate a flight to Israel. Reports that foreign-airline security responsibilities were divided or unclear, including a 2024 state comptroller finding, have intensified scrutiny of the Israeli agencies and ministries involved.8910
Related stories
Version history
- version 3 · Netanyahu has ordered a foreign-flight security review as a 2024 oversight finding and opposition criticism intensify scrutiny of how the co-pilot was cleared.
- version 2 · Passenger accounts now detail how the alleged attacker was tied with a headphone cable, how a doctor treated Machchhar and how Netanyahu honoured four people involved.
- version 1 ·



