World · Saudi Arabia
Saudi court sentences Kenyan mother to 100 lashes after birth outside marriage
Esther Wanja Muthoni was convicted in Riyadh in October, according to The Star’s report via BBC. The punishment follows restrictions on flogging announced in 2020 that retained exceptions.
A Saudi court sentenced Kenyan mother Esther Wanja Muthoni to 100 lashes after birth outside marriage.
- The Star reports an additional year of banishment.
- The 2020 flogging restrictions retained exceptions.
- The punishment’s timing remains unclear.
What's new
- Reports on November 10 and 11 describe a mother’s sentence of 100 lashes.
- The Star, via BBC, reports that the sentence also includes one year of banishment.
- The timing of the punishment and whether banishment means deportation remain unclear.
According to a November 11 report from The Star via BBC, a Riyadh criminal court ruled in October that Kenyan domestic worker Esther Wanja Muthoni had engaged in extramarital sex after she bore a child and imposed a punishment of 100 lashes. The Guardian and The New York Times also reported the flogging sentence.123
Birth and court proceedings
The Star described Muthoni as 40 and a mother of five, and reported that her sentence included one year of banishment. It remains unclear when the punishment will be administered or whether the banishment will mean deportation to Kenya, the report said.3
That report said Muthoni, who was legally working as a domestic worker, conceived a child in the course of a short-lived relationship with an Egyptian man. She gave birth in staff accommodation in August 2025. Both The Guardian and The Star reported Muthoni’s statement that her son’s father was no longer in Saudi Arabia.13
The Star reported that police detained her for questioning about the pregnancy after she was taken to hospital. Rights groups told The Guardian that her case reached the authorities because hospitals were required to report unmarried women who gave birth.13
Muthoni had a court translator but reportedly no lawyer, according to The Star. According to the outlet, she did not file an appeal and had been seeking for over a year to go back to Kenya accompanied by her one-year-old son. “I don’t think I can endure those lashes,” Muthoni said, as quoted in its report.3
Limits of the flogging reform
Saudi Arabia announced a reform in April 2020 to end flogging as a judicial penalty, The Guardian reported. But the rights organisation ALQST told the newspaper that the change covered only ta’zir offences, for which judges have discretion over punishment, rather than all offences.1
ALQST said flogging remained available for some hudud offences, which carry punishments fixed under Islamic law. The Star likewise reported that exceptions survived the 2020 restrictions and said the court relied on an interpretation prescribing 100 lashes for sex outside marriage.13
The Guardian reported that sex outside marriage is criminalised under Saudi Arabia’s sharia system. Rights groups told the newspaper that women bear a disproportionate share of the punishment. ALQST’s acting director, Maryam Aldossari, condemned the ruling and said Muthoni should have been allowed to return to Kenya instead.1
Calls for assistance
Ekaterina Porras Sivolobova, founder of Do Bold, told The Guardian she had been unable to secure assistance from Kenyan authorities for Kenyan women. The newspaper further said Saudi Arabia had deferred a scheduled trip by Reem Alsalem, who serves as the UN special rapporteur on violence against women and girls. Alsalem said she intended to raise individual cases during the visit.1
The Guardian said it had approached the Saudi government for comment. Muthoni told the newspaper: “I don’t deserve this.”1
Why it matters
For European readers assessing Saudi Arabia’s reform commitments, the case illustrates the importance of distinguishing an announced restriction from its legal exceptions. The New York Times framed the sentence as evidence of a gap between reform promises and judicial practice, particularly for unmarried foreign workers.123
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 1 ·


