SlovakNews

Slovakia

Slovak Court Sentences Gymnasium Attacker to 25 Years as Prosecution and Defense Both Vow to Appeal

A Pezinok court found Samuel S. guilty of double murder over the January 2025 Spišská Stará Ves gymnasium killings and sentenced him to 25 years rather than the life term prosecutors sought, as authorities confirmed the separate Staškov school attacker was 13 years old and said police had been warned about the school five days earlier.

Live Version: 5Sources: 12Perspectives: 2Updated:
Foto: Pravda · source

What's new

  • Court convicted Samuel S. of double murder and an attack on a classmate, sentencing him to 25 years in a maximum-security prison
  • Judge ordered psychiatric treatment and payment of damages; prosecution and defense both say they will appeal
  • Staškov attacker confirmed as a 13-year-old eighth-grade student, now in a psychological detention facility
  • Police had received a criminal report from the Staškov school five days before the attack; Inspection Service now probing police response
  • Separately, a 17-year-old allegedly attacked a 14-year-old boy near a Bratislava school

Slovakia's Specialized Criminal Court in Pezinok found Samuel S. guilty of double murder and an attack on a classmate over the January 2025 gymnasium killings, sentencing him to 25 years in a maximum-security prison rather than the life term prosecutors had sought; both sides say they will appeal, so the verdict is not yet final. Authorities also confirmed the separate deadly Staškov school attack was carried out by a 13-year-old, and said police had received a warning report about the school five days beforehand.16

The attack

On 16 January 2025, Samuel S. killed deputy school director Mária Semančíková, 51, and student Alena Čarnogurská, 18, with a knife at the gymnasium in Spišská Stará Ves, and wounded another student, Barbora N., also 18, according to SITA. He then fled to nearby woods, where police later arrested him.145

According to SITA, Samuel S. had bought the knife at an army-surplus shop in Poprad. Police reporting cited by SITA said he told his father he had killed two, possibly three, people, and attempted suicide in the forest but was too weak to carry it out.1

Prosecutor's case

Delivering closing arguments before judge Milan Cisarik, prosecutor Michal Šoltýs said the attack was planned and executed in cold blood and that protecting society required the harshest possible punishment. He asked for placement in a maximum security prison and for protective psychiatric treatment, saying he saw no hope that a lower sentence would lead to the defendant's rehabilitation.2548

According to Hospodárske noviny, Šoltýs said such a high sentence for a young person had never before been imposed in Slovakia, and argued that a 25-year term would see Straško freed at 43, still "at the peak of his strength" and dangerous to society. SITA reported a similar but not identical calculation attributed to the prosecutor, placing release at around age 40.31

According to STVR, Šoltýs also asked the court to order compensation for the families of the victims as part of the sentence.1

Defendant's response

Samuel S. does not deny committing the act but fundamentally disputes its legal classification as aggravated premeditated murder in the indictment, according to reporting carried by Topky.sk/TASR and Standard.sk.54

According to Prešovak.sk, Samuel S. denies planning the attack, saying he brought the knife to school out of fear of a court-ordered protective treatment order and that he attacked only after a conflict with the deputy headmistress. Hospodárske noviny reported that he described himself as "nevinný" (innocent) and rejected any suggestion the act was planned.63

Background and earlier rulings

According to SITA, an individual study plan had been imposed on Samuel S. in December 2024, a measure he blamed on the deputy director. The same report said witnesses testified he had announced his intentions beforehand, quoting him as saying "Ja ju zabijem, prisahám, že ju zabijem" and "Zaslúžia si trest, zhynú v pekelnej bolesti".1

SITA also reported that in April, both the Regional Court and the Supreme Court of Slovakia rejected requests by Samuel S. to be released from custody pending trial.1

Separate incident

A 61-year-old teacher died of her injuries in the Staškov attack, while a 44-year-old teacher was taken to hospital with a stabilized chest wound and a student was left in serious condition, according to TASR, Hospodárske noviny and other reporting.1693

TASR reported that the suspect is a 13-year-old eighth-grade student, who was placed in an appropriate psychological detention facility. TASR also reported that police had received a criminal report from the school five days before the attack, concerning an incident that occurred the previous week, and that the Office of the Inspection Service has opened an investigation into how police handled that earlier report. Slovak opposition politicians condemned the attack and demanded that Prime Minister Robert Fico's government take action against those responsible or resign.169

Closing arguments from defense and victims

A lawyer representing the victims' families also asked the court for a life sentence, saying she saw no mitigating circumstances in the case, according to TASR.1

Defense attorney Ľuboš Dobrovič countered by requesting a 15-year sentence with placement in a medium-security prison, citing Samuel S.'s young age as a mitigating factor. Samuel S. himself asked the court for an extraordinary reduction of his sentence, saying, "Myslím si, že nie som zlý človek. a single wrongdoing shouldn't brand someone a sinner forever, since by that logic everyone would be guilty, and he contended that a lengthy prison term would not help him reform and that he poses no threat to society.1

The Specialized Criminal Court in Pezinok, presided over by judge Milan Cisarik, found Samuel S. guilty of double murder and an attack on a classmate and sentenced him to 25 years' imprisonment in a maximum-security facility, ordering him to undergo outpatient psychiatric treatment and to pay roughly ten thousand euros in damages to the victims' families, according to TASR and Hospodárske noviny. Hospodárske noviny reported that both the prosecution and the defense intend to appeal, meaning the verdict is not yet legally final and the case will go to the Supreme Court of Slovakia.16

Evidence of planning and psychiatric assessment

Prosecutors presented evidence they said showed the attack was planned, including internet searches by Samuel S. for the phrase "cross the Rubicon" and messages he sent classmates referencing "dissection" and "massacre," according to Aktuality.sk. Denník Prospekt separately reported testimony pointing to planning and cold-blooded conduct.410

Psychiatric expert Ivan André testified that Samuel S. has an immature personality with a disturbed relationship to himself and the world around him, was dangerous to his surroundings and posed a persistent suicide risk at the time of examination, according to Pravda. André said Samuel showed a persistent hateful reaction toward women, did not appear to suffer from a mental illness in the strict sense, and said he did not believe Samuel intended to murder when he went to school that day.2

Autopsy findings presented at trial found deputy director Mária Semančíková had six wounds inflicted with extremely high intensity of violence from the same instrument, while student Alena Čarnogurská died from 26 wounds and bled out at the school, Pravda reported. Samuel S. said hearing the autopsy findings was terribly hard, saying he acted terribly poorly and that Alena did not deserve it, though he disputed causing a wound on Semančíková's lip, saying it arose during resuscitation.2

Defense attorney Ľuboš Dobrovič argued that Samuel S.'s control and recognition abilities were reduced during the attack, citing the expert's finding that he did not go to the gymnasium intending to murder. The prosecutor countered that the expert testimony instead refuted the defense's arguments. Pravda also reported that Samuel S. had twice been previously convicted for disorderly conduct and dangerous threats, and that police completed their investigation in December 2025 with a recommendation to prosecute.2

Other recent incidents and government response

Bratislava regional police spokesperson Michal Szeiff said the case is being handled as a minor offence against civil coexistence. The victim was treated at the Národný ústav detských chorôb children's hospital for injuries to his right ear, and the alleged attacker was reportedly seen near the school the following day.2

Prime Minister Robert Fico held a discussion with about 70 students from two schools in Bánovce nad Bebravou over the summer, telling them Slovakia must decide fundamental questions independently and voicing opposition to mandatory migration quotas and EU voting changes, Pravda reported. The government has since approved legislation establishing an integrated system for protection against radicalization and mobilization to violence, according to Pravda.2

The European Commission's Representation in Slovakia condemned the violence and said schools should be a safe space for pupils and teachers, while the Slovak Psychotherapeutic Society issued guidance urging adults to listen to children and check in on one another. "Adults should notice one another more, and ask how their children, relatives and friends are doing," the society said, according to TASR.1

Why it matters

The verdict shows a Slovak court stopping well short of the life sentence sought by prosecutors and victims' representatives for a young offender's premeditated violence, with an appeal to the Supreme Court still to come. It lands amid mounting scrutiny of school safety after the Staškov attack, now known to have been carried out by a 13-year-old despite a police report filed five days earlier, and a separate assault near a Bratislava school, fueling opposition criticism of the government.162

Related stories

Version history

  1. version 5 · Added the verdict: Samuel S. was convicted of double murder and sentenced to 25 years, not life, with both sides planning to appeal; also added confirmed details on the 13-year-old Staškov attacker, the prior police report, and a separate Bratislava assault.
  2. version 4 · Added new trial testimony on planning evidence, psychiatric assessment and autopsy findings, and confirmed the Staškov school attacker was a 13-year-old now in psychological detention.
  3. version 3 · Added the defense's 15-year sentence proposal, the victims' representative's life-sentence request, Samuel S.'s own plea for leniency, the pending verdict, and new details and political fallout from the Staškov school attack.
  4. version 2 · Added the prosecutor's previously unreported request for compensation for the victims' families, per STVR.
  5. version 1 ·