World · United States of America, Israel, State of Palestine
US Senate Again Blocks West Bank Accountability Resolution
A resolution forced by Senator Chris Van Hollen under the Foreign Assistance Act, demanding a State Department report on Israeli violence against Americans and Palestinian detainees in the West Bank, failed in a near party-line vote, with record Democratic support and a pledge from Van Hollen to keep pressing.
The US Senate again blocked Chris Van Hollen's Senate Resolution 852 demanding State Department accountability for West Bank killings and Palestinian detentions, as parallel congressional pressure on Israel policy grows.
- Senate blocked resolution 47-51 (Al Jazeera cites 47-53)
- Resolution was S. Res. 852, invoked under FAA Section 502(b)
- Record 46 of 47 Democrats supported the measure
- 45 Senate Democrats sent letter to Netanyahu on settler violence
- House Democrats also pushed Israel aid-cut votes
What's new
- Resolution identified as Senate Resolution 852, forced under FAA Section 502(b)
- Yeni Şafak and Anews corroborate the 47-51 tally via the discharge-motion count
- 45 Senate Democrats sent a letter urging Netanyahu to curb settler violence
- New victim detail: Omar Assad's death at an Israeli checkpoint, two 17-year-old Americans shot in 2024
- House Democrats also push aid cuts: 103 backed a Massie amendment; Rep. Ro Khanna reportedly detained
On September 29-30, the US Senate rejected Senate Resolution 852, a measure Senator Chris Van Hollen forced onto the floor using his authority under Section 502(b) of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961, which would have required the State Department to produce, within 30 days, an accounting of the deaths of nine American citizens in the West Bank since 2022 and of how Israel treats Palestinian detainees, including minors, according to the resolution's sponsors.1236
The vote
The measure, sponsored by Democratic Senators Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, Tim Kaine of Virginia and Bernie Sanders of Vermont, was defeated in a vote reported as 47-51 by the Guardian, Arab News, Al-Monitor and Reuters, though Al Jazeera also cited a 47-53 tally. Van Hollen invoked the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 to compel a vote, which allows lawmakers to compel State Department human-rights reporting, according to Al Jazeera. Had the report not been produced, it could have led to limits on American aid to Israel, according to Arab News, Al-Monitor and Reuters.1234
Every Republican senator voted against the resolution except Rand Paul of Kentucky, who voted in favour, while every Democrat backed it except John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, who voted against, according to Arab News, Al-Monitor and Reuters. The Intercept reported that Fetterman's dissent came even though one of his constituents, a 19-year-old from Philadelphia, was among the most recent Americans killed by settlers in the West Bank.2457
Nine Americans killed
Van Hollen argued that neither Israel nor the United States had held anyone responsible for the killings of nine American citizens in the West Bank across roughly a four-year span. Among the cases the Guardian highlighted was that of Sayfollah Musallet, 20, from Tampa, who died in July 2025 after Israeli settlers assaulted him, with a single-source account describing settlers encircling him for over three hours while preventing an ambulance from reaching him. Khamis Ayyad, 40, from Cicero, Illinois, died from inhaling smoke weeks afterward when settlers torched vehicles and houses, according to the same source. Other cases named included Tawfic Abdel Jabbar and Mohammad Khdour, shot dead in 2024, Ayşenur Ezgi Eygi and Amer Rabee, shot 11 times in 2024, according to the Guardian.1
Van Hollen said: "In just over four years, nine American citizens have been killed on the West Bank by violent Israeli settlers or members of the Israeli security forces and there has been zero accountability."7
Al Jazeera and the Intercept detailed further cases underlying the resolution: Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh, shot in the head and killed by Israeli forces in Jenin in May 2022, and Aysenur Ezgi Eygi, shot in the head by an Israeli soldier in September 2024. The resolution also pointed to the case of Mohammed Ibrahim, a 16-year-old Palestinian-American from Florida who was taken into custody in February 2025 and kept in pretrial detention for nine months with no access to his family, a period during which, according to a single-source account, he shed close to a quarter of his body weight. That same source also noted an Israeli military raid on Birzeit University in June that targeted Palestinian-American students, along with a toll of at least 44 Palestinian deaths in Israeli military detention since October 7, 2023, and the absence of any convictions in cases where Israeli settlers killed Palestinian civilians dating back to 2020.27
The Daily Caller offered further particulars on earlier incidents, in a single-source account: Omar Assad, an American, suffered a fatal heart attack brought on by stress after being restrained at an Israeli checkpoint in the village of Jiljilya, while Tawfic Abdel Jabbar, 17, was shot in the head in January 2024, and Mohammad Ahmad Alkhdour, also 17, was shot twice in the head and killed the following month.9
Rising settler violence
Multiple outlets reported that attacks by Jewish settlers on Palestinians in the West Bank have surged this year. According to a UN report cited by the Guardian, there were 1,732 recorded settler attacks resulting in injury or property damage during the year ending October 2025. Human Rights Watch found that settler violence and expanding settlements had uprooted roughly 5,900 people across 107 Palestinian communities since January 2023, and that displacement in just the first four months of 2026 exceeded the total for 2025, per the Guardian's single-source account. The same source reported that Israeli settlement growth has driven upward of 36,000 Palestinians out of their homes.1
Arab News, Al-Monitor and Reuters noted that Israel has held the West Bank under occupation since 1967, and that international law–per the UN and most nations–deems its settlements there unlawful. Those same outlets reported that no country has received more total US foreign aid since World War Two than Israel.245
Political shift among Democrats
According to Responsible Statecraft, 46 out of 47 Democratic senators backed the measure–an unprecedented level of support for this kind of vote–pointing out that a comparable Sanders resolution in 2024 had gone down 72-11. Sanders introduced a comparable resolution on Gaza in January 2024, which received 11 votes, according to the Hill.87
Sanders told the Senate: "Enough is enough. Washington can no longer fund this bloodshed while turning a blind eye, in Gaza and in the West Bank alike," adding, "It's time to end our complicity." Kaine characterized the situation on the ground as "pretty dire," noting that Israeli media and human rights groups alike had recorded "numerous visible attacks targeting Palestinian communities in the West Bank, none of which have been met with accountability."7
Montana Republican Steve Daines called on fellow senators to defeat the resolution, stating, "I urge my colleagues to vote no on this resolution so we can stand with our ally Israel as they beat back the scourge of Iranian-backed terrorism." The Guardian pointed out that a separate Sanders effort to halt arms sales to Israel drew 18 votes in November 2024, and that by April 2026, 40 of 47 Democrats opposed a $295 million bulldozer deal, with 36 Democrats voting against a $152 million sale of 1,000-pound bombs.31
Wider backdrop
The vote came against the backdrop of the Gaza war, in which tens of thousands of Palestinians have been killed, and a war with Iran that Arab News, Al-Monitor and Reuters described as unpopular with Americans frustrated by higher energy prices. Surveys referenced by the same outlets suggest Republicans under Donald Trump risk losing control of Congress in the November 3 midterms, while Benjamin Netanyahu's right-wing coalition may also lose power in Israel's October 27 election.245
Analyst John Ramming Chappell said it was "remarkable that nearly every Democratic senator voted to scrutinize Israel's human rights record."8
Van Hollen vows to continue
Wider congressional pressure
Pressure over Israel policy has also grown in the House, where the Daily Caller reported that 103 Democrats backed a Massie amendment in September to cut military aid to Israel, following 37 Democrats who supported a similar measure in April 2024. The outlet also reported that California Democratic Representative Ro Khanna was detained by Israeli authorities in July.9
Separately, Middle East Eye reported that 45 Senate Democrats signed a letter asking Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to act to stop and intervene against settler violence and to set up a trustworthy system for investigating violations of the law.7
Why it matters
The vote signals a shift in how US lawmakers, particularly Democrats, are willing to publicly question Israel's conduct despite the country's status as the largest recipient of American aid since World War Two. Parallel moves – a 45-senator letter to Netanyahu and House votes to cut Israel aid – suggest the pressure extends beyond this single resolution, even as reporting on detained minors and unresolved settler killings deepens scrutiny of accountability gaps.2379
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 3 · Added detail identifying the measure as Senate Resolution 852 under FAA Section 502(b), new sourcing corroborating the 47-51 tally, fresh victim details (Omar Assad, two 17-year-olds), and new context on House aid-cut votes, Ro Khanna's detention, and a 45-senator letter to Netanyahu.
- version 2 · New reporting adds detail on Van Hollen's use of the Foreign Assistance Act, additional victim cases (Abu Akleh, Ibrahim, Birzeit raids), discrepancies in the reported vote tally, and Van Hollen's pledge to keep pressing after the resolution's defeat.
- version 1 ·


