SlovakNews

World · United States of America, United Kingdom

Trump’s BBC defamation case proceeds as judge dismisses separate Florida claim

A federal judge in Florida has allowed Donald Trump’s defamation allegations against the BBC to advance without deciding their merits. A separate claim under Florida’s unfair trade practices law was dismissed.

Live Version: 2Sources: 4Perspectives: 1Updated:
Donald Trump
Foto: Daniel Torok / Wikimedia Commons · Public domain · source

What's new

  • The judge rejected part of the BBC’s request to dismiss the case.
  • Trump’s defamation allegations can proceed, but he must still prove them.
  • The court dismissed the claim under Florida’s unfair trade practices law.

Donald Trump’s defamation lawsuit against the BBC can proceed in Florida, according to reports on 11 November, after federal judge Jeffrey T Kuntz partly rejected the broadcaster’s dismissal request. The BBC reported that the lawsuit seeks $10 billion. The judge allowed the defamation allegations to advance but dismissed a separate claim under Florida law.123

Editing at the centre of the case

The dispute concerns comments Trump made before the US Capitol insurrection on 6 January 2021. The BBC brought together two passages delivered nearly 55 minutes apart in its Panorama documentary, Trump: A Second Chance, which the Guardian dates to 2024. According to Anadolu Agency, the combined remarks appeared in a clip lasting 12 seconds.134

According to the BBC’s account of the lawsuit, Trump alleges that the broadcaster deliberately and maliciously altered his speech to deceive viewers. The BBC has apologised for the edit and said the broadcast wrongly suggested that Trump had explicitly urged violent action.2

The broadcaster sought to have the case dismissed. According to its reporting, the BBC argued that the programme failed to satisfy the legal requirements for defamation and had not been available in the United States. The documentary was not broadcast in Florida.123

Allegations still require proof

Kuntz found that Trump had adequately alleged actual malice for the litigation to continue. The judge considered the editing itself a possible basis for that conclusion at this stage. That finding concerned the sufficiency of Trump’s allegations, rather than a determination that the BBC was liable.123

The judge also accepted that Trump had plausibly alleged damages, based on his claim that the documentary harmed his reputation when released toward the election. Trump must nevertheless establish that he actually suffered damage from the broadcast; the ruling does not settle that question.13

The BBC reported that proof of the claims and any resulting damages could be considered at summary judgment or trial. In a separate decision, Kuntz rejected Trump’s allegation based on the Florida law governing deceptive and unfair business practices. According to the BBC, he concluded that the documentary was not commercial speech.123

Responses and the next stage

The BBC expressed surprise at the decision while acknowledging the court’s authority. A spokesperson said: “We remain confident in our position and will continue to respond through the proper legal process.” Trump described the ruling on Truth Social as a “huge victory”.12

The proceedings also require Trump to answer questions from the broadcaster’s lawyers. In October, a Florida magistrate judge ordered him to attend a deposition by 11 December, with possible sanctions if he did not comply, according to the Guardian and the Irish Times.13

Why it matters

For European readers, the case concerns a British broadcaster defending its editing of a US president’s speech in a Florida court. The defamation proceedings will continue, but neither liability nor actual damages has been established.123

Videos

Judge Says Trump’s $10 Billion BBC Defamation Case Can Proceed · NTD News
Defamation lawsuit filed by Trump against BBC gets greenlight to proceed · WPLG Local 10
Judge allows President Donald Trump's defamation lawsuit against BBC to proceed · KVUE
Trump's $10 Billion BBC Defamation Case Can Proceed, Florida Judge Rules · US TrendWatch

Related stories

Version history

  1. version 2 · This update identifies 2024 as the year of the Panorama documentary; the ruling allowing the defamation case to proceed remains unchanged.
  2. version 1 ·