SlovakNews

Sport · United Kingdom

Manchester City Vows to Fight as Guilty Verdict Draws Fierce Reaction

Manchester City has confirmed it will appeal its conviction on 114 of 115 financial rule-breach charges, with chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak pledging to clear the club's name. A sanctions decision looms by the end of January.

Live Version: 3Sources: 12Perspectives: 2Updated:
Foto: Sky Sports · source

What's new

  • Manchester City found guilty of every charge tied to financial rule breaches between 2009-10 and 2017-18, and all but one charge over failing to cooperate with the investigation
  • Chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak pledges in a letter to fans to clear the club's name
  • CEO Ferran Soriano tells European Football Clubs board the case could take years to resolve, says he is confident of winning
  • Former players Micah Richards and Jamie Carragher react publicly; Carragher calls for City's Premier League titles to be stripped
  • La Liga president Javier Tebas urges the toughest possible sanction against City

An independent Premier League commission has found Manchester City guilty of breaching the league's financial rules across nearly a decade, convicting the club on 114 of 115 charges – every count tied to financial rule violations between 2009-10 and 2017-18, plus all but one charge over its failure to cooperate with the investigation – the club confirmed on September 30, 2026. Manchester City, which insists it is innocent, plans to appeal ahead of Friday's deadline; The Guardian reported the appeal must conclude within 12 weeks, after which the commission has 30 days to rule, meaning a sanctions decision is expected by the end of January.2347

The verdict

According to the commission's findings, Manchester City systematically broke Premier League rules for close to a decade, filing accounts that concealed the club's true financial position from auditors and the league. The commission determined that City created fraudulent agreements and padded club income by roughly £900 million across the nine seasons from 2009-10 through 2017-18.123

The BBC and ESPN reported that City was found guilty on all charges tied to financial rule breaches from 2009-10 through 2017-18, plus every count except one concerning claims the club obstructed the inquiry – a total of 114 guilty verdicts out of 115 charges.47

According to Al Jazeera, the scheme allegedly worked by having City's ownership group in Abu Dhabi covertly supply money that was masked as sponsorship income, with actual commercial partners contributing only a portion of the stated payments while the Abu Dhabi United Group quietly made up the difference. Sky Sports separately reported the club arranged sham commercial deals to artificially inflate revenues and reduce costs by more than £900 million, a description Al Jazeera's sourcing did not confirm in the same terms.23

The commission stated that City 'clearly intended to circumvent the rules,' according to Al Jazeera. The outlet reported that accurate financial reporting by the club would have shown it far exceeding permitted spending thresholds.3

Premier League chief executive Richard Masters characterized this as the biggest case the league has ever handled. "This disciplinary case and this decision are the most significant in Premier League history," he said.13

Possible sanctions

A separate hearing before the independent commission will determine what punishment Manchester City receives, according to Sky Sports. The Premier League will put forward a proposed sanction and City will argue its case before the commission decides. According to The Guardian, the appeal process has to wrap up within 12 weeks of Friday's deadline, and the panel then gets a further month to issue its ruling, putting a sanctions decision around the end of January. Sky Sports chief correspondent Kaveh Solhekol said, "We are not going to find out what the punishment is anytime soon."25

Sky Sports reported that possible sanctions range from expulsion from the league, a points deduction, a transfer ban or a fine. Football finance expert Kieran Maguire, cited by Al Jazeera, suggested any sanction should be far larger than those handed to Everton and Nottingham Forest in recent seasons, potentially in the range of 40 to 60 points; even a 40-point deduction would have left City 18th in the table last season, according to that estimate.23

The Premier League reached an agreed £10 million fine with Chelsea earlier this year over self-reported historic breaches, The Guardian reported, a sanction rival executives argue underscores the need for a far harsher penalty given the scale and duration of City's alleged offences.5

Sky Sports News senior reporter Rob Dorsett said a very large points deduction would be the only route by which City could end up playing in the Championship. "If City are to end up playing in the Championship, the only way they can get there is if they're given a very large points deduction," he said. CNN reported that pundit Ian Wright called for what he termed "unprecedented punishment," and that a large deduction could be spread across multiple seasons to hamper the club's future competitiveness.24

Sky Sports reported that if City were relegated via a points deduction, the English Football League would likely accept the club, which would also receive parachute payments; if City were instead expelled from the Premier League, EFL clubs would need to vote on whether to accept it. Sky Sports also noted that evidence presented to the tribunal only extended to 2018, and that material used in the investigation originated from Portuguese hacker Rui Pinto.2

Reaction and appeal

Manchester City denies wrongdoing, according to multiple outlets, and issued a statement saying it is "both disappointed and surprised by the opinion of the Premier League commission." The club added: "The club is innocent of the accusations made by the Premier League" and said "a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists in support of all of its positions." It said it "will therefore be relentless, and where necessary proactive, in any and all appropriate regulatory and legal forums."123

Manchester City chief executive Ferran Soriano called the verdict, according to Al Jazeera, "a single false accusation and a Premier League conspiracy theory."3

Sky Sports reported that Manchester City has until Friday, October 2, to exercise its right to appeal, and that the process is expected to conclude by Christmas, with a judgment delivered in the new year and before the end of the season. Solhekol cautioned that an appeal requires firm legal grounds: "When it comes to an appeal, you can't just say 'I'm angry, I'm going to appeal.' You have to have strong legal grounds."2

Sky Sports reported that attorneys nationwide are advising various Premier League clubs on potential legal action against Manchester City, though clubs are reportedly holding off on filing suits until the appeal concludes. Several City sponsors declined to comment on the findings while the process remains ongoing, according to the same report.2

The Guardian reported that Manchester United, Arsenal, Tottenham and Liverpool reserved their right to pursue legal action against City two years ago and have since held informal conversations about compensation claims. Rival executives cited the Everton case as precedent, noting the club had to hand Burnley over £35 million after Burnley successfully claimed it would have survived relegation if Everton's penalty had come earlier. A club source told the Guardian relegation for a single season would be insufficient, saying the commission "has to arrive at a punishment that is proportionate for years of sustained and deliberate cheating."58

BBC reported that senior football figures want Manchester City's sanction decided before the end of the season. Independent Football Regulator chairman David Kogan said the commission's decision "raises serious issues" and that the regulator "has powers to assess the suitability of owners, directors and executives" which it would use "where appropriate." Conservative peer Lord Cruddas called for a criminal investigation, saying, "If accounts have been falsified and auditors have been misled, then it is potentially a criminal matter."48

In a letter to supporters, Manchester City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak vowed to continue the fight, stating, per Al Jazeera, 'Our confidence and intent in proving the club's innocence is just as strong as when this began.' Speaking to the European Football Clubs board on Monday, Soriano indicated, according to Al Jazeera, that resolving the matter fully could take years, and he separately told City staff in a video message, per the BBC, that the commission had disregarded 'irrefutable evidence.' Micah Richards, who used to play for City, told the BBC the verdict left him feeling 'devastated,' and former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher argued the club should lose its Premier League titles, saying: 'I think the titles should be taken off their list. City have not just hurt their own players.' Speaking at a London football summit, La Liga president Javier Tebas described the alleged decade-long pattern of violations as 'very serious' and said football needed 'a before-and-after moment,' while ex-Tottenham manager Mauricio Pochettino argued the harm was irreversible no matter what punishment followed.347

Context

Manchester City was taken over by the Abu Dhabi United Group, and Deutsche Welle reported the club had won the league only once in 71 years before that takeover; the outlet also reported City has since won the Premier League eight times in the past 14 years. Al Jazeera pointed out that the club captured its first piece of silverware in three and a half decades when it lifted the FA Cup in 2011, followed by its inaugural Premier League crown in 2012–both occurring during the timeframe the charges address.13

In 2020, UEFA banned Manchester City from European competitions, a decision the Court of Arbitration for Sport later overturned, though it fined the club €10 million, according to Al Jazeera. Everton had earlier been penalized 10 points for a financial violation, a punishment later cut to six on appeal, and was directed to pay Burnley in excess of £35 million after Burnley contended it would have stayed up had Everton faced discipline sooner; during that same stretch, Nottingham Forest was docked four points over financial infractions.3

Why it matters

The Premier League has called the case the most significant in its history, and the eventual sanction could reshape competitive balance in English football for years. The Guardian reported that four rival clubs have reserved the right to sue City and held informal talks about compensation claims, while the Independent Football Regulator's chairman said he would examine the suitability of City's owners and executives. Reaction from across football – including calls to strip City's titles and demands from La Liga's president for the harshest possible sanction – underscores how far the fallout could extend beyond the pitch.1345

Videos

"எப்படியும் CHEATERS-னு SOLLATHA போறீங்க" - Manchester City 115 Charges Case · VILAIYATTU MANRAM
What PUNISHMENT is Man City going to face? · Ahmed's Goal
HAALAND TO BARCELONA OR REAL MADRID?🤯 Manchester City 115 Charges Verdict EXPLAINED! RELEGATION? · Vigi Watches

Related stories

Version history

  1. version 3 · Added detail on the 114-of-115 charge breakdown and new reactions from club leadership, pundits and football officials, including Al Mubarak's pledge, Soriano's EFC remarks, Richards, Carragher and Tebas.
  2. version 2 · Added new reporting on the appeal timeline, rival clubs' reserved legal threats and regulatory/political scrutiny of Manchester City's ownership.
  3. version 1 ·