Sport · United Kingdom
Manchester City Spent £450m on Transfers After Learning of Guilty Verdict, ESPN Reports, as UK Minister Warns of 'Ultimate Sanction'
New detail from the Premier League ruling shows Manchester City's disguised funding scheme inflated sponsorship income to £949.94m while only £119.25m was genuine, with ESPN reporting the club knew of the guilty verdict in July before spending over £450m on transfers. UK Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy calls expulsion the 'ultimate sanction,' former chairman David Bernstein questions the board's future, and MP Jeremy Corbyn demands a relegation-level points deduction ahead of Friday's appeal deadline.
The Premier League's commission detailed how Manchester City disguised £830m of owner funding as sponsorship revenue and reportedly kept spending after learning of the verdict, prompting UK politicians to warn of severe sanctions.
- £830.69m in owner funds disguised within £949.94m reported commercial income
- ESPN: City spent £450m+ on transfers after learning of verdict in July
- UK minister Lisa Nandy: expulsion is the 'ultimate sanction'
- Ex-chairman Bernstein questions whether City's board should be suspended
- MP Corbyn demands a relegation-level points deduction
What's new
- ESPN reports Manchester City was told of the guilty verdict in July, before spending over £450m on transfers over the summer
- Commission breakdown shows only £119.25m of £949.94m in reported commercial income was genuine, with £830.69m in 'tagged sums' from owners
- UK Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy calls expulsion the Premier League's 'ultimate sanction' while affirming City's right to appeal
- Former Manchester City chairman David Bernstein says sanctions 'cannot be merely financial' and questions whether the board should be suspended
- Independent MP Jeremy Corbyn demands a points deduction severe enough to relegate Manchester City, calling the judgment 'seismic'
New detail from the Premier League's independent commission shows Manchester City's disguised funding scheme inflated commercial income to £949.94 million across nine seasons, of which only £119.25 million represented genuine sponsor fees, with the remaining £830.69 million made up of 'tagged sums' funnelled from owners. ESPN reported that City was informed of the guilty verdict in July, before the club went on to spend more than £450 million on transfers over the summer. As the club prepares to appeal by Friday, October 2, senior figures have signalled sanctions could go well beyond a fine: UK Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy called expulsion the league's 'ultimate sanction,' former City chairman David Bernstein said the findings were 'damning beyond belief' and questioned whether the board should be suspended, and independent MP Jeremy Corbyn demanded a points deduction large enough to relegate the club.698
The verdict
After a four-year probe, the Premier League brought charges against Manchester City in February 2023, and a ruling from an independent commission followed a hearing that started in September 2024 and lasted roughly twelve weeks. The panel found the club guilty on nearly all of the 115 charges, which involved financial rule breaches spanning nine seasons between 2009-10 and 2017-18.124
The charges included failure to provide accurate financial information and failure to cooperate with Premier League investigations between December 2018 and February 2023. In the league's official statement, chief executive Richard Masters said the ruling 'establishes the facts of what happened at Manchester City during this period' and 'how the club systematically broke Premier League rules for nearly a decade.' For its part, Manchester City said it was 'both disappointed and surprised' by the panel's conclusions, rejected any suggestion of wrongdoing, cited what it termed 'a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence' backing its position, and vowed to keep contesting the ruling through additional appeals.1268
No sanction had been determined as of publication, and the independent commission's full findings had not yet been published. Reported possible penalties range from a fine to a points deduction or a transfer ban.641
According to ESPN, Manchester City had already been informed of the commission's guilty findings in July, before proceeding to spend more than £450 million on transfers during the summer window.6
Khaldoon Al Mubarak, who chairs the club and also leads Abu Dhabi's Mubadala investment fund, voiced ongoing belief that City would ultimately be cleared, stating: "our confidence and intent in proving the club's innocence is just as strong as when this began."54
Manchester City chief executive Ferran Soriano released an internal video message to staff calling the verdict a 'Premier League conspiracy theory,' arguing the entire case rested on 'a single false accusation' that owner funds were routed to the club through Abu Dhabi sponsors. He pledged the club would remain 'relentless' in exploring every avenue available, both 'the independent appeal process and also all other legal avenues.' City must lodge its formal appeal by Friday, October 2.1395
Reaction from the game
Mauricio Pochettino, the United States men's national team head coach who managed Tottenham Hotspur from 2014 to 2019, said that if City were found guilty, supporters had "lived through a period of deception."123
Pochettino, who also managed Southampton for 15 months and Chelsea for one season during the period covered by the charges, said Tottenham went 18 months without making a transfer while building its new stadium and was the only Premier League club to operate under such a freeze while still competing for titles and a top-four finish. He noted Chelsea were champions in 2016-17, with his Tottenham side finishing second.12
Reports indicated that other Premier League clubs were consulting lawyers about potentially pursuing compensation in light of the ruling.2
Several Premier League clubs have gone further than merely consulting lawyers, filing legal documents to formally reserve the right to pursue Manchester City for compensation over the verdict.7
Joe Hart, the 39-year-old former Manchester City goalkeeper who won the Premier League twice with the club, said he continued to trust the chairman. "There's nothing making me doubt Khaldoon.. he has handled his role at Manchester City really well," Hart said in an interview with BBC Radio 5 Live, adding that no final outcome has yet emerged from the ongoing legal dispute.58
Roberto Mancini, who managed Manchester City during part of the period covered by the charges, said the club was 'not guilty' but appeared to acknowledge holding a second contract during his tenure, remarking that the arrangement was 'not my problem but theirs, probably.'10
UAE-UK relations under scrutiny
Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan owns Newton Investment and Development LLC outright, which in turn holds a controlling stake in Manchester City, while Silver Lake owns roughly 17 percent as a minority investor.4
According to Semafor, the verdict is seen as tainting one of the UAE's prominent soft-power achievements, with rival supporters framing it as evidence that City bought its way to success. Khaldoon Al Mubarak met with Andy Burnham, who called Abu Dhabi "huge partners" for investment in Manchester's poorest areas.7
Analysts cited by AGBI said the case sits within a broader web of ties between Britain and the Gulf. It's not," he said, adding that Gulf investment had "helped transform Manchester" and London Gateway.4
Kristian Coates Ulrichsen said the reaction could prove more significant than an earlier dispute over a blocked media acquisition: "We saw how Abu Dhabi responded with anger to the Telegraph backlash and this is bigger and potentially more damaging."4
Background
According to the Guardian, Manchester City's difficulties trace to a 2018 investigation by Der Spiegel citing leaked internal documents. Uefa then handed City a Champions League ban and a €30m fine in 2020, but the Court of Arbitration for Sport threw out the penalty, ruling that the statute of limitations had expired on several of the accusations.1
The Premier League case, covering nine seasons, has included allegations that City falsified financial details centred on player and coach payments; the BBC reported that the charges also concerned inflated sponsorship revenue from connected companies and off-the-books payments intended to circumvent financial rules.12
According to the commission's findings, City allegedly set up fraudulent sponsorship agreements from 2009-10 through 2017-18, in which sponsors covered only part of the contracted payments while Abu Dhabi United Group Investment & Development Ltd, the club's then-owner, supplied the balance; the panel further found that City's records misrepresented its true financial standing to auditors and regulators.68
The commission's ruling further detailed a disguised funding arrangement worth about £830.6 million, and found the club had hidden a further £70 million in costs. It rejected City's argument that a disputed sum was in fact an Abu Dhabi government loan, and concluded that evidence given by several factual witnesses called on the club's behalf 'was false.' The findings also described sham image-rights arrangements involving players and former manager Roberto Mancini.3
A more detailed breakdown showed Manchester City recorded £949.94 million in commercial income across the nine seasons, of which only £119.25 million represented genuine base fees from sponsors; the remaining £830.69 million constituted 'tagged sums' effectively supplied by the club's owners and funnelled through sponsors to disguise the true source of the funding.6
Possible sanctions and outside criticism
Football finance expert Kieran Maguire, speaking on The Overlap, estimated Manchester City could face a points deduction of roughly 40 to 60 points if sanctioned, noting Everton received a six-point deduction for a single-season breach while City's case spans nine seasons. He said the Premier League could not relegate City to League One or League Two, as that would be a decision for the EFL.7
Soriano has warned that, if the appeal fails, the club could theoretically face relegation or be stripped of titles won since its 2008 takeover.7313
La Liga president Javier Tebas criticized the Premier League's handling of the case at a Financial Times summit, saying City 'has impunity' while other clubs face fines and points deductions, and warning the situation was 'damaging for an institution's image.' The Premier League's chief executive declined to comment on the timing of any sanction.7
UK Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy said expulsion from the league represented the Premier League's 'ultimate sanction,' while stressing that Manchester City remained entitled to a fair appeal. Former Manchester City chairman David Bernstein said sanctions 'cannot be merely financial,' calling the findings 'damning beyond belief' and questioning whether the club's current board should be suspended. Independent MP Jeremy Corbyn called for a points deduction 'large enough to relegate' the club, describing the judgment as 'seismic.' Labour's Lucy Powell said City's trophies were not tainted by the findings.68
Manchester City currently sits five points behind league leaders Arsenal, with a game in hand, according to reports citing the club's league position amid the dispute.7
Fallout among rivals, fans and players
Other Premier League clubs are reportedly consulting lawyers about pursuing compensation over the ruling.6
Why it matters
The case tests the Premier League's ability to enforce its own financial rules against one of its most successful and state-backed clubs, with implications for competitive fairness across European football; La Liga's president has already accused the league of tolerating 'impunity.' The outcome could also affect Britain's diplomatic and investment relationship with the United Arab Emirates.247
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 5 · Added ESPN's report that City knew of the guilty verdict in July before spending £450m on transfers, a detailed breakdown of the disguised £830.69m funding scheme, and new political reactions from Lisa Nandy, David Bernstein, Jeremy Corbyn and Lucy Powell on potential sanctions.
- version 4 · Added new details on Roberto Mancini's apparent acknowledgment of a 'double contract,' rival clubs formally filing compensation claims, and the 2018 Football Leaks/2014 Uefa settlement background.
- version 3 · Soriano brands the verdict a 'conspiracy theory' and confirms the Friday appeal deadline, as the commission's ruling details an £830m disguised-funding scheme, false witness evidence, and analysts weigh sanction precedents from Everton to Derby.
- version 2 · The Premier League has now officially confirmed the guilty verdict via statement, with CEO Richard Masters calling it the league's most significant disciplinary case, Manchester City has issued a formal denial vowing a 'relentless' appeal, and outside figures including La Liga's Javier Tebas and analyst Kieran Maguire have weighed in on the fairness of the process and possible penalties.
- version 1 ·



