Business · United Kingdom
Man City Scandal Escalates: Rivals Demand Resolution This Season as Compensation Claims Could Reach Billions
New reporting shows the fallout from Manchester City's guilty verdict deepening further: four Premier League clubs have written to the league demanding the case be concluded this season, rival clubs have reserved the right to sue City for damages that one analyst says could run into billions of pounds, and Etihad Airways has detailed its anger at how the Premier League communicated its findings. City's appeal is expected to take up to 12 weeks and sanctions could be imposed before it concludes, while whistleblower Rui Pinto has lost Portuguese witness protection.
Manchester City's guilty verdict over roughly £900m in hidden funding is triggering escalating legal fallout, with rival clubs demanding quick resolution and compensation claims potentially reaching billions.
- City found guilty of all 115 financial breach charges, 2009-2018
- Appeal under way, could take 12 weeks; sanctions may come first
- Four clubs wrote to Masters demanding case end this season
- Rival clubs' damages claims could reach billions, analyst says
- Etihad says it wasn't consulted, is seeking legal advice
What's new
- Four Premier League clubs wrote to chief executive Richard Masters demanding the case be resolved before the end of this season
- Other Premier League clubs wrote to Manchester City reserving the right to claim damages over the breaches
- GiveMeSport's Ben Jacobs reported sources believe rival clubs' compensation claims could run into billions of pounds
- Etihad Airways said it was not consulted during the investigation and is seeking legal advice, while 'categorically' rejecting any improper commercial arrangements
- Manchester City's appeal process has begun, with a potential 12-week timeline and possible sanctions imposed before it concludes
- Rui Pinto, whose leaked documents helped trigger the Premier League investigation, has lost witness protection from Portuguese authorities
Fallout from Manchester City's guilty verdict widened further as four Premier League clubs wrote to chief executive Richard Masters demanding the case be concluded this season, other clubs reserved the right to sue City for damages that one analyst said could reach into the billions, and Etihad Airways detailed its anger at how the Premier League communicated its investigation findings, even as it maintained its support for the club.514
The verdict
The commission concluded that Manchester City systematically broke Premier League financial rules for nearly a decade, arranging sham contracts with commercial partners to artificially inflate revenues and reduce costs so as to appear compliant with spending limits. Sources indicate that if the club's financial disclosures had been truthful, it would have significantly exceeded permitted spending thresholds.261
Reports indicate that City's Abu Dhabi owners covertly financed over £830 million of the approximately £900 million total, with the funds disguised as sponsorship revenue; a separate account estimates the hidden financing at nearly $1 billion, describing an arrangement in which sponsors covered only a portion of their stated obligations while the Abu Dhabi United Group supplied the balance.25
Richard Masters, the Premier League's chief executive, characterized the ruling as clarifying exactly what transpired at Manchester City during the period, calling it the league's most consequential case to date.68
The Athletic reported that the panel convicted Manchester City on 114 of the 115 total allegations, a figure the Premier League corroborated, confirming 80 guilty findings on financial counts and 34 guilty findings out of 35 charges tied to non-cooperation with investigators. The charges comprised 54 counts of providing inaccurate financial information, 14 counts of failing to disclose accurate player and manager payments, seven counts of breaching profit and sustainability rules, five counts of breaching financial fair play equivalents, and 35 counts of failing to cooperate.2
City's response and the appeal
Manchester City has denied wrongdoing throughout the process and says it will contest the ruling. In a statement the club said a "comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence that exists in support of its position" and argued the commission's opinion "contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe."146
Manchester City said it was "both disappointed and surprised by the opinion of the Premier League commission" and vowed to be "relentless, and where necessary proactive, in any and all appropriate regulatory and legal forums" as it pursues its appeal, which the club expects to take up to 12 weeks.514
Manager Pep Guardiola stated that he was confident the club's achievements had been earned honestly through performances on the field. We don't have any doubts," adding that he trusted the club's account of events. Former City midfielder and 2025 Ballon d'Or winner Rodri said he had been told by the club "to be relaxed, as they had done everything correctly."2
Manchester City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak said in a statement that "nothing has changed and our confidence and intent in proving the Club's innocence is just as strong," while chief executive Ferran Soriano told staff in a video that the case against the club rested on a "single false accusation" that owners' personal money had been secretly funneled through sponsors, calling it "just not true."28
Lisa Nandy said of the findings, "It's incredibly serious, the Premier League report is incredibly stark."6
What sanctions could follow
A separate hearing is still to determine sanctions, which the Premier League says could range from a fine to expulsion from the league. According to one estimate, penalties could be far heavier than those imposed on Everton and Nottingham Forest, potentially reaching 40 to 60 points; even a 40-point deduction would have left City 18th in the table last season.42
Former Football Association chairman David Bernstein said, "If the appeal fails, Manchester City cannot stay in the league, they have to suffer." Analysts have also noted it remains unclear whether players such as Erling Haaland have contract clauses tied to heavy sanctions, though the case has so far done little to stop the club attracting and keeping top players, including a reported $169 million signing of Enzo Fernández this month.62
Should City be expelled, the club would have to apply to the Football Association to rejoin the football pyramid, starting in League Two, with any return requiring a vote by the Premier League and EFL's member clubs, according to Sky Sports.4
Legal costs and precedent
According to the Guardian, both sides have run up more than £100 million in combined legal costs over the eight-year case, with the Premier League's own costs expected to exceed £70 million. Under Premier League process, a winning party can typically expect to recoup about 70% of its costs from the losing side, meaning the league could be awarded almost £50 million once a compensation hearing concludes.1
The case draws comparison with Everton, found guilty of profit and sustainability breaches in 2024, when the league pushed for £4.9 million in costs but was awarded £1.7 million after Everton argued the sum was excessive.1
Background
Allegations of financial irregularities first surfaced in 2018 after leaked club emails and documents, and Der Spiegel published material that year alleging the club had disguised direct investment from its owners as sponsorship income from partners including Etihad and Etisalat. The Premier League opened its formal case more than three years before the verdict and says City failed to cooperate with investigators between 2018 and 2023.49
Manchester City's financial conduct previously drew UEFA scrutiny: European football's governing body opened a formal investigation in March 2019 after the Der Spiegel leaks and, in February 2020, found the club guilty of overstating sponsorship revenue between 2012 and 2016, fining it €30 million and banning it from the Champions League for two seasons. The Court of Arbitration for Sport overturned the European ban in July 2020. Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, the UAE's vice president and deputy prime minister, took ownership of the club through Abu Dhabi United Group in 2008, buying it from Thailand's former premier Thaksin Shinawatra, and went on to establish City Football Group in 2013 to oversee its soccer operations.2
The period under scrutiny coincides with City's ascent to the top of English football, a stretch that saw Pep Guardiola take charge as manager in 2016, the club sweep the Champions League, Premier League and FA Cup in a single season, secure four straight league championships, and post a 100-point campaign. Commentary on the club's coaching legacy has used language such as "the biggest sporting cheating scandal ever" to describe the scale of the findings, and the club's rise is described by one outlet as having been achieved at least partly through evasion of financial regulation.34
Wider fallout in football
Lawyers acting for rival Premier League clubs have begun examining potential litigation against Manchester City in the wake of the verdict, according to Sky Sports.4
Former player and pundit Jamie Carragher said Manchester City should be stripped of titles won during the period in question, while the club continues to deny wrongdoing and insists it holds irrefutable evidence supporting its position.4
The fallout deepened on 1 October as Everton was ordered to pay compensation to Burnley over the impact of financial breaches on Burnley's relegation during the 2021-22 season, a precedent being watched closely amid talk of similar claims against Manchester City. Sponsor Etihad Airways said it was considering legal action against the Premier League over its handling of communications during the investigation, even as it insisted "we stand with the club." Separately, Conservative peer Lord Cruddas said that if accounts had been falsified and auditors misled, "it is potentially a criminal matter" under the Fraud Act, while multiple Premier League clubs were reported to be seeking legal advice on potential compensation claims against City.7
Etihad Airways went further on 1 October, saying it "categorically rejects any finding, conclusion or implication that it was involved in improper commercial arrangements" and that it had not been approached or consulted during the commission's investigation. The airline, which has sponsored City's shirt since 2009, said it was "deeply concerned by the way this matter has been communicated publicly," pointing to a "lack of clarity and transparency" and "selective disclosure of information" that it said had harmed its standing even though it was not named in the published ruling; it said it was now exploring its legal options while reaffirming its backing of the club.5
City's appeal is expected to take up to 12 weeks, and Jacobs reported that any punishment could be handed down and take effect before the appeal process concludes. Separately, Rui Pinto, the whistleblower whose leaked documents helped trigger the Premier League's investigation, has lost the witness protection he had been granted by Portuguese authorities, according to Sky Sports.145
GiveMeSport reported that four Premier League clubs have written to Masters urging that the case be concluded within this season, while other clubs have written directly to Manchester City reserving the right to claim damages. Senior correspondent Ben Jacobs said sources believe the scale of compensation claims "would be in the billions," with clubs potentially arguing they would have finished higher, qualified for European competition or avoided relegation had City been sanctioned earlier.14
Owners face regulator scrutiny
England's newly empowered Independent Football Regulator, created by the UK government in 2025, said the guilty verdict "raises serious issues" and confirmed it has the power to assess the suitability of Manchester City's owners, directors and executives to hold a licence - a process that could, in theory, lead to a review of Abu Dhabi United Group's control of the club. Chief executive David Kogan said the regulator "will use these powers where appropriate."16
Manchester mayor Andy Burnham said he would be "really concerned" if City's Abu Dhabi ownership decided to sell up in the wake of the ruling, describing Abu Dhabi United Group as "such a huge partner in the building of modern Manchester," while adding that he could not intervene further in the regulatory process. Abu Dhabi United Group has invested billions of pounds in the club and the city, and the UK-Abu Dhabi trading relationship is estimated to be worth around £30 billion a year.1
Manchester City Women address the case
Manchester City Women manager Andree Jeglertz addressed the guilty verdict at a media session ahead of the team's next fixtures, saying it was "business as usual" for his squad and declining to comment further, while confirming the women's team operates under the same club ownership. Defender Jade Rose said the players were focused solely on football.6
The Premier League confirmed there is no active investigation by Women's Super League football into Manchester City Women, and the charges against the men's club concern separate financial rules. The women's team currently sits top of the WSL table with 12 points from four matches and opened its Women's Champions League campaign with a draw against Bayern Munich; City Women are next set to face Real Madrid.6
City Football Group's global reach questioned
Australian Professional League officials said they would wait to see how the Manchester City situation develops before raising concerns about Melbourne City, while City Football Group figure Steve Rosich said of the Premier League case, "No it doesn't concern us. More developments and conclusions are still expected as the legal process continues."8
Why it matters
The scandal is now reverberating well beyond Manchester City itself: rival clubs are formally pressing the league for a swift resolution and reserving the right to pursue damages potentially worth billions, sponsor Etihad is weighing legal action over how it was treated during the investigation, and England's football regulator is assessing the suitability of City's Abu Dhabi owners, all while the club's appeal - which could take up to 12 weeks - proceeds alongside the possibility that sanctions are imposed before it concludes.51416
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 5 · Added new reporting on rival clubs writing to the Premier League and Manchester City over compensation potentially worth billions, details of City's and Etihad's formal statements, the 12-week appeal timeline, and Rui Pinto losing witness protection.
- version 4 · Added reporting on widening legal fallout - Etihad considering action against the Premier League, Everton's Burnley compensation order, rival clubs seeking advice on claims, calls for a criminal probe, and scrutiny of City Football Group's Melbourne City.
- version 3 · Added new reporting on the Independent Football Regulator's scrutiny of Manchester City's Abu Dhabi owners, the 2 October appeal deadline, Mayor Andy Burnham's concerns, a detailed charge breakdown, City's UEFA history, and reaction from Manchester City Women.
- version 2 · Added detail on possible expulsion mechanics, City's historic spending figures, and new fallout including rival clubs exploring litigation and sponsors declining comment.
- version 1 ·



