SlovakNews

Sport · United Kingdom

Manchester City Fallout Grows as Rivals Weigh Compensation Claims and Mancini Denies Any Wrongdoing

As Manchester City's reported guilty finding on 114 of 115 Premier League financial charges continues to reverberate, former Stoke boss Tony Pulis says he still feels cheated over the 2011 FA Cup final, rival clubs are taking legal advice on compensation, and ex-City manager Roberto Mancini has publicly denied the club did anything wrong, even as the Premier League maintains its silence.

Live Version: 5Sources: 11Perspectives: 3Updated:

Listen to the story

Short version

0:001:01
Tap to zoom, Esc to close
Foto: Deutsche Welle · source

What's new

  • BBC reports Premier League clubs are seeking legal advice on compensation, with one source suggesting individual claims and a lawyer proposing a centralised process instead
  • Former Stoke City manager Tony Pulis said he still feels 'cheated' over City's 2011 FA Cup final win and wants the trophy reconsidered
  • Roberto Mancini, who managed City to the 2011 FA Cup and 2011-12 title, publicly denied the club was found guilty and dismissed remuneration-disclosure allegations against himself
  • Manchester City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak reiterated that 'nothing has changed' in the club's confidence of proving its innocence
  • New detail emerged on how the 115 charges break down, including 35 relating to non-cooperation with the Premier League's investigation

Manchester City's reported finding of guilt on 114 of 115 Premier League financial charges continued to reverberate this week, as rival clubs took legal advice on possible compensation and reactions multiplied across the game. Former Stoke City manager Tony Pulis said he still feels 'cheated' over City's 2011 FA Cup final win, while ex-City manager Roberto Mancini publicly denied the club had been found guilty of any wrongdoing. Manchester City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak repeated that 'nothing has changed' in the club's confidence, even as the Premier League has yet to issue any official confirmation or sanction.1210

Infographic

Manchester City Reportedly Found Guilty in Finance Case as Ian Wright, Roy Keane Demand Punishment and Rodri Defends Club. Sources: BBC, The Guardian, ESPN and others. Manchester City Finance Case. February 2023. City charged with 115 rule breaches. September 2024. Hearing begins behind closed doors. December. Hearing ends after 12 weeks. Reported 25 Sep. City reportedly guilty on 114 charges. 115. charges brought against City. 114. charges reportedly found guilty. 2009 to 2018. period covered by breaches. Ian Wright & Roy Keane. City should be punished for cheating. Rodri. City's success was earned, not bought. Premier League yet to confirm verdict. City expected to appeal decision. Rival clubs seek legal advice on compensation. Possible sanctions: fines, points deduction, expulsion
Built from the article's facts; every word on it is checked.

The verdict, still unconfirmed

The Premier League brought charges against Manchester City in February 2023, the culmination of a four-year investigation into alleged financial rule violations spanning nearly ten years. According to The Athletic, an independent panel's hearing determined the club was liable on all but one of the 115 counts. The Standard reports that the case has now finally concluded, with City deemed liable on nearly all of the charges, though neither the club nor the league has officially confirmed this outcome, and there has been no formal acknowledgment that the three-member panel has actually delivered its ruling.1247

According to The Esk, the charges reportedly break down into 54 counts relating to failure to provide accurate financial information, 14 concerning manager and player remuneration disclosure, five involving UEFA Financial Fair Play compliance, seven relating to Premier League Profitability and Sustainability Rules, and 35 concerning City's alleged failure to cooperate with the investigation. The inquiry was reportedly triggered not by regulatory discovery but by a November 2018 leak of internal documents published by the German magazine Der Spiegel.7

In a statement issued the Friday the news broke, Manchester City said the "Premier League process remains ongoing with significant elements to be completed, and subject to strict confidentiality." A club spokesperson later said the club's position had not changed. City has previously said it possesses "a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence" supporting its case, though some reports describe the club as having consistently denied all the charges, a characterisation not explicitly confirmed by City itself.14

Manchester City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak has repeated in an open letter and subsequent comments that the club's confidence in proving its innocence remains strong. "Here's what I said to my family: The Premier League process still has a long way to run and our confidence and intent in proving the club's innocence is just as strong as when this began," he wrote. The Premier League has continued to decline to comment, a spokesperson saying, "It's a confidential process, we're not commenting at all." As of the latest reports, the league has made no official announcement, and no potential punishment has been indicated.56

Al Mubarak reiterated this stance later in the week, saying, "There is so much noise swirling around us, nothing has changed. We have faced challenges together before and have prevailed."210

Pundits and a City player react

The reported finding has drawn public reaction from figures inside and outside the club.7

7

"They cannot take it off us," he said of City's honours, adding that success "is paid by effort, hardship, being shoulder to shoulder every day."7

Reaction extended beyond current City figures. Former Stoke City manager Tony Pulis said he still feels "cheated" over Manchester City's 2011 FA Cup final win, telling reporters, "When do we get our FA Cup? That is what all Stoke fans have been asking me since the news broke on Friday," and adding that Stoke "won't ever get that day back and the chance to celebrate around Stoke-on-Trent with the cup and medals we so honestly fought for." Roberto Mancini, who managed City to that FA Cup and the 2011-12 Premier League title, pushed back on the reported finding, saying, "I don't think Manchester City were found guilty, on the contrary," and dismissed allegations concerning non-disclosure of his own remuneration as "not my problem, but theirs if anything."210

Appeal and possible sanctions

Manchester City are expected to appeal if the reported verdict is confirmed, according to multiple reports. Under Premier League rules, the club would have 14 days from any formal verdict announcement to lodge an appeal, with the process expected to conclude within roughly 12 weeks and any hearing held in a single block of no more than five days, according to the Guardian. Any City appeal would reportedly be based solely on the finding of guilt rather than any punishment, since no penalty has yet been determined or announced. It remains to be seen how City will be sanctioned, and whether competing clubs will assert that they were the rightful winners of trophies City claimed instead of them in those years.2345

If an appeal fails, City could pursue arbitration as a final route, though the Guardian reports this carries stricter criteria and would likely require showing that the panel or appeal board abused the legal process. City have recently been through arbitration with the Premier League over separate rules on transactions with associated parties, a case that produced a partial ruling against the league before the two sides reached a settlement in September 2025 that ended the litigation.21

Should City's challenges fail, sanctions reported as available under Premier League rules range from fines to sporting penalties such as points deductions, and, at the most severe end, expulsion from the league, according to the Guardian. City may also be stripped of titles won during the period in question. No such sanction has yet been indicated by the league.2346

Financial fallout and possible compensation claims

Premier League clubs are reported by the BBC to be seeking legal advice about potential compensation following the reported guilty finding, with one source suggesting individual clubs may pursue their own claims while a leading lawyer told the BBC the process could instead be centralised by the Premier League.132

Precedents exist in recent cases: Everton were docked six points in 2023 for breaching profit and sustainability rules, a penalty reduced to two on appeal, while Nottingham Forest received a four-point deduction for similar breaches; separately, Everton were ordered in June to pay Burnley £35m after a commission found their PSR breach contributed to Burnley's relegation, assessing Burnley's loss at roughly £26m against a claim of £51.7m.127

Why it matters

The case touches the integrity of a decade of Premier League results, with title outcomes, relegations and prize money all potentially affected, and it has already split opinion among players and pundits over whether City's era should be recognised or erased once the league confirms any verdict and sanction.237

Videos

Manchester City reportedly found guilty of almost 115 financial charges · Al Jazeera English
Ben Jacobs EXPLAINS Man City punishment & KEY DIFFERENCES between Everton & Nottingham Forest cases! · talkSPORT

Related stories

Version history

  1. version 5 · Added new reaction from Roberto Mancini (denying guilt) and Tony Pulis (still feeling cheated over the 2011 FA Cup), detail on the 115-charge breakdown, and BBC reporting on how rival clubs may pursue compensation.
  2. version 4 ·
  3. version 3 · Updated to reflect reports that the case has now concluded, with pundits Ian Wright and Roy Keane demanding punishment for Manchester City and City's Rodri publicly defending the club's record, while the Premier League still has not issued an official verdict.
  4. version 2 · Updated to reflect that the Premier League has still made no official confirmation of any verdict or punishment, while Manchester City's chairman and a club spokesperson reiterate the club's confidence and unchanged position.
  5. version 1 ·