SlovakNews

World · United States of America

Hochul vows rape-law change as James takes over Cornell probe

New York’s governor pledged to close a legal loophole involving voluntarily intoxicated victims as the attorney general began overseeing the active criminal investigation.

Live Version: 3Sources: 8Perspectives: 3Updated:

Listen to the story

Short version

0:001:02
Tap to zoom, Esc to close
Foto: The Straits Times · source

What's new

  • New reporting says Cornell opened a months-long Title IX investigation in November 2024.
  • Students, family members and faculty criticized university leadership at a public forum.
  • A bill introduced in June would extend incapacity protections to some voluntary-intoxication cases.

New York’s governor, Kathy Hochul, pledged on Oct. 2 to seek a change in state rape law concerning voluntarily intoxicated victims as Attorney General Letitia James took control of the active criminal investigation into allegations that seven Cornell University students drugged and raped a woman at a fraternity house in 2024.345

Infographic

Hochul vows rape-law change as James takes over Cornell probe. Sources: The Guardian, BBC, The Independent and others. Cornell assault allegations. October 2024. Jane Doe alleges drugging and rape. November 2024. Cornell launches Title IX investigation. September 2026. Jane Doe files civil lawsuit. reported 2 Oct. James takes over active criminal investigation. seven. Students accused in civil lawsuit. several months. Cornell Title IX inquiry. Civil lawsuit. Alleges seven students drugged and raped her. Lawyers for two defendants. Deny clients committed sexual assault
Built from the article's facts; every word on it is checked.

Case reassigned after new information

After transferring the case to James, Hochul vowed to seek a change in New York law concerning voluntarily intoxicated victims. She said voluntary drug or alcohol use should not prevent an intoxicated person from being legally unable to consent. James now oversees the active criminal inquiry instead of Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten.345

Al Jazeera reported that a bill introduced in June would extend New York’s incapacity-to-consent provisions to certain cases involving voluntary intoxication. The proposal’s fate remains unresolved.6

James said her office would review the facts, gather evidence and interview witnesses, and would pursue prosecutions if warranted. Hochul said those responsible for safeguarding the plaintiff had let her down, and she faulted Cornell police and the county prosecutor for their response to the allegations.145

Conflicting accounts of the evidence

In September, the ex-Cornell student referred to as Jane Doe brought a civil suit. According to the lawsuit, seven students raped her after she was drugged inside Chi Phi’s house; one news report says the filing identifies ketamine as the substance used. The lawsuit names the seven men, Cornell, the fraternity and other defendants, and claims the university failed to protect her or impose adequate punishment.124

Lawyers representing two defendants denied that their clients committed sexual assault, according to The Guardian. One of those lawyers said his client neither touched the plaintiff nor used drugs. No criminal charges were filed after the alleged incident was reported to Cornell police.1

Van Houten defended his office’s earlier decision, saying the available evidence did not reach the threshold required for prosecution. He said prosecutors had received only a campus police officer’s signed statement that suggested the encounter was consensual and that the plaintiff had not been drugged. He also said he had not received her detailed account and that much of the information disclosed more recently had not reached his office.12

Cornell offered a different account of the evidence it supplied, saying material from its internal investigation was sent to the district attorney. The university said that material included a Snapchat group conversation about a sexual encounter with the plaintiff. Before Hochul reassigned the case, Van Houten had announced that his office would reopen it in light of new information.12

Cornell’s response under scrutiny

Cornell said it suspended Chi Phi indefinitely and that its investigation resulted in some students being disciplined or expelled. It declined to detail the individual sanctions, citing student privacy requirements. The chapter remains barred from campus, and The Independent reported that its members unanimously removed the accused students from its rolls.134

The university also agreed to retain outside lawyers to conduct an independent examination of its handling of the allegations, according to The Guardian. Separately, The Straits Times reported that Hochul called for an independent review intended to assess whether Cornell fulfilled its responsibilities to protect students and pursue justice.14

After Jane Doe contacted police in November 2024, Cornell began a Title IX inquiry that lasted several months. At a public forum, students, family members and faculty criticized university leadership and discussed their experiences with sexual assault and the university’s response.3

The dispute comes against a longer record of changes to fraternity oversight at Cornell. In 2019, the university required Greek-life chapters to employ independent monitors for events and accept random security inspections. Cornell temporarily halted fraternity parties in 2022 following allegations of sexual assault and students being drugged.3

Why it matters

The case shows how university discipline, campus policing and criminal prosecution can reach different conclusions about the same sexual-assault allegations. It has also prompted a broader debate over New York law and whether intoxicated victims receive adequate protection when their use of drugs or alcohol was voluntary.145

Related stories

Version history

  1. version 3 · New reporting details Cornell’s Title IX inquiry and campus criticism, and identifies a June bill addressing some voluntary-intoxication cases.
  2. version 2 · Hochul has vowed to seek a change in state rape law, while James has taken control of the case as an active criminal investigation.
  3. version 1 ·