World · France, Holy See (Vatican City State)
Pope Leo Condemns Assisted Dying as 'False Compassion' Amid Ongoing Scrutiny of Lourdes Abuse Meeting
New reporting details Pope Leo XIV's broader four-day France trip – including a rebuke of the country's new assisted-dying law, a rare address to President Macron at the Élysée Palace, fresh specifics on Marko Rupnik's stalled Vatican trial, and the political backdrop of France's approaching presidential election – alongside continued fallout from his closed-door Lourdes meeting with seven abuse survivors.
Listen to the story
Short version
Pope Leo XIV's France visit combined a private meeting with abuse survivors, a rebuke of assisted-dying legislation, a rare Élysée Palace address to Macron, and appearances tied to France's abuse crisis and upcoming election.
- Pope Leo met 7 abuse survivors for ~2 hours in Lourdes
- Called assisted dying 'false compassion' amid new French law
- Met Macron at Élysée Palace during Paris leg
- Paris Mass attendance disputed: 700,000 to 800,000
- Le Pen, now leading polls, attended Paris Mass
What's new
- Pope Leo condemned France's new assisted-dying law as 'false compassion,' saying 'what is legal is not necessarily moral'
- Newly detailed itinerary shows Pope Leo rode the popemobile along the Champs-Élysées, met Macron at the Élysée Palace, and passed an estimated 300,000 people en route to Notre Dame Cathedral
- Paris Mass attendance remains disputed, with Vatican figures ranging from an initial 700,000 to a later 800,000 against about 600,000 pre-registered
- Marine Le Pen, who attended the Paris Mass, is reported to currently lead polls ahead of April's presidential election
Pope Leo XIV, the first American pontiff, spent four days touring Paris, Metz and Lourdes – including a rare address to President Emmanuel Macron at the Élysée Palace – meeting privately for nearly two hours with seven survivors of clerical sexual abuse, addressing migrants and European unity, and denouncing France's new assisted-dying law as a form of 'false compassion'; new reporting has since detailed both the survivors' meeting and the Vatican's slow-moving canonical case against accused priest Marko Rupnik.71613
Private meeting with survivors
In Lourdes, Pope Leo held a private, one-on-one meeting with seven people who had been sexually abused by clergy in France.7911
The Holy See Press Office said the pope "met each of them individually and in private, listening to their stories, to the pain and suffering they had endured," before gathering everyone together to thank them for their "painful testimony" and reaffirm his commitment to ensuring the harm they experienced would not happen to others.815
Addressing French bishops separately, Pope Leo praised what he described as their courageous response to abuse committed against minors within the clergy, telling them: "In recent years, you have faced with determination the painful scourge of abuse committed against minors by members of the clergy or in an ecclesial context."739
He also urged clergy toward humility, saying admission of mistakes is indispensable for spiritual growth, and told bishops to "continue along the path already taken, maintaining the utmost vigilance."38
Named survivors and the scale of the French abuse crisis
The independent CIASE commission, formed in 2019 to examine abuse within the French Catholic Church, concluded in its October 2021 final report that upwards of 210,000 minors had been abused by nearly 3,000 clergy and religious figures across the 1950-2020 period; factoring in abuse committed by lay Church employees pushes the commission's overall estimate to roughly 330,000 victims over some seven decades.672
Roughly 2,000 people reported sexual abuse by clergy seeking reparations, according to the reparations body.16
The dossier also flagged other episodes deepening France's reckoning with abuse, including allegations that pupils suffered severe physical and sexual mistreatment while enrolled at the Notre-Dame de Bétharram boarding school, as well as claims leveled against the late Abbé Pierre, a French priest and humanitarian once widely revered.1
The Rupnik case
Marko Rupnik, a Slovenian Jesuit priest, is accused of assaulting more than two dozen women across a thirty-year span. Rupnik has not commented publicly on the accusations.136712
According to the survivors, the Church needs that same truth just as urgently as they do.13
Rupnik's mosaics at Lourdes' basilica were covered up following the abuse accusations.613
Crowds and wider visit
It marked the first official state visit by a pope to France in nearly two decades. Pope Leo, who leads 1.4 billion Catholics worldwide, celebrated an outdoor Mass at Place de la Concorde in Paris; the Vatican put attendance at about 800,000, exceeding the roughly 600,000 who had pre-registered, though other reporting cited the Vatican's initial estimate at 700,000.91125
Earlier that day, Pope Leo rode in the popemobile along the roughly two-kilometre Champs-Élysées, greeted by flag-waving crowds, with an estimated 300,000 people watching him pass en route to Notre Dame Cathedral. He also met President Emmanuel Macron and delivered a rare address at the Élysée Palace.1315
He then moved on to Lourdes, which draws about three million pilgrims a year to its shrine of the Virgin Mary.421
At Lourdes, Pope Leo prayed silently at the Grotto of Massabielle, where 14-year-old Bernadette Soubirous said she witnessed apparitions in 1858, and covered part of the route to the sanctuary on foot without shoes, greeting pilgrims along the way.15
At Lourdes, Pope Leo celebrated an outdoor Mass attended by an estimated 150,000 people.317
The pope's visit caused hotel prices in Lourdes to soar, with some one-night stays reaching over €2,000, according to reporting on the trip.1
Beyond Lourdes, the four-day trip included a speech at UNESCO, an address in Metz on Europe's Christian roots and the pursuit of peace and unity, and a visit to an association supporting migrants – echoing the pope's earlier condemnation of indifference toward migrants during a June visit to Spain. The trip unfolded months before France's presidential election.1
Reactions
Pilgrims attending the Paris Mass described the atmosphere among the crowds.4
Five of the seven survivors who met with the pope later appeared at a press briefing in Lourdes open only to those invited, though the dossier offered no specifics on what they said beyond noting the event occurred.6
Pope condemns assisted dying as 'false compassion'
During the Lourdes leg of the visit, Pope Leo criticized France's new right-to-die legislation, telling clergy and pilgrims that "what is legal is not necessarily moral." He said that "it is precisely in the name of this inalienable dignity of the human person that we must reject the temptation to cause death under the guise of false compassion."7
This followed France's parliament passing a June law that grants some adults with incurable illnesses the right to assisted dying, a step the Catholic Church in France labeled a 'serious rupture.' Cardinal Jean-Marc Aveline said the pope's central message revolved around defending human dignity, adding, "How will he convey this in France? We shall see," while academic Martin Dumont said he would be surprised if the pope adopted a confrontational stance.1
Why it matters
The visit thrusts France's Catholic abuse crisis and the Church's tensions with an increasingly secular society into the same frame, as Pope Leo criticized France's assisted-dying law days after facing criticism over the closed survivors' meeting. Newly detailed Rupnik trial proceedings and the visit's timing months before France's presidential election underscore how the papacy must navigate accountability demands alongside moral and political debates in one of Europe's most secularized Catholic nations.27131
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 4 · Added newly reported details on Pope Leo's Paris itinerary – including his Élysée Palace meeting with Macron, the Notre Dame Cathedral procession, and his prayer at the Grotto of Massabielle – alongside disputed Mass attendance figures and Marine Le Pen's reported polling lead.
- version 3 · Added new reporting on Pope Leo's condemnation of France's assisted-dying law, fresh details on Rupnik's stalled Vatican trial and expulsion history, the broader itinerary of his France trip, and the visit's political backdrop ahead of France's presidential election.
- version 2 · Added new reporting detailing the meeting's logistics, named individual survivors and cases, noted criticism of the meeting's small format, clarified CIASE abuse figures, and confirmed the Rupnik trial remains ongoing after the Vatican's July rejection of acquittal reports.
- version 1 ·



