World · United States of America
US judge temporarily blocks Trump administration’s Washington park closure
Ana Reyes halted plans to close East Potomac Park for a golf-course redevelopment. The judge found that the government had broken federal laws in pursuing its deadline.
A federal judge has temporarily blocked the Trump administration’s closure of East Potomac Park for redevelopment.
- Reyes found the government had violated at least two federal laws.
- Trump proposed a 15-month closure for a championship golf-course redesign.
- The BBC says the order lasts until 28 November.
- Government lawyers face an inquiry into possible misrepresentations and ethical breaches.
What's new
- Reyes temporarily blocked the proposed closure and ordered work suspended.
- The restraining order lasts until 28 November, according to the BBC.
- An inquiry will examine whether government lawyers misled the court or breached ethical rules.
US District Judge Ana Reyes has temporarily blocked the Trump administration from closing East Potomac Park in Washington DC for a golf-course redevelopment, according to reports published on 15 November. The ruling interrupts a proposed 15-month closure that President Donald Trump said would allow the site to host international tournaments.123
Temporary limits on closure
Reyes found that the government had violated at least two federal laws in trying to meet an arbitrary deadline. She rejected the administration’s explanations for closing the park as “pretextual”. According to the Guardian, the court also ordered a temporary halt to work at the site.123
The order remains in force until 28 November, the BBC reported. Reyes said officials had offered no credible account of how maintaining the status quo through a temporary restraining order would damage the government during the dispute.2
The ruling distinguishes public access from the operation of the golf facilities. According to the Jerusalem Post, the administration does not have to keep golf operations running, but Reyes said it “cannot use the absence of golf operations as a reason to exclude the public”.3
Competing plans for the course
The proposed redesign would replace the park’s facilities with one 18-hole championship course. Trump said the renovated venue would remain available to the public and could stage events including the US Open and Ryder Cup. He announced a closure lasting 15 months.13
Trump has defended the renovation by describing the existing course as being in poor condition. According to the BBC, he also said the site contained dangerous trees and a deteriorating, hazardous seawall. Those descriptions were the president’s stated reasons for undertaking the work.2
According to the BBC, the redevelopment dispute reached court in February through a lawsuit filed by the DC Preservation League and additional plaintiffs. The preservation group says the plan breaches federal regulations and statutes. The plaintiffs also argue that it would alter the accessible course’s character and put its cost beyond existing users, according to the Guardian.123
Tree removal and lawyers’ conduct
Tree removal has become another issue in the case. The BBC reported that the National Park Service began cutting hundreds of trees in October after notifying Reyes only 15 hours before work was due to start. Reyes then ordered a stop to tree removal and required advance notice of permanent changes.2
Reyes said the removal of trees and failure to inform the preservation group had undermined the government’s credibility. She has ordered an inquiry into whether Justice Department lawyers repeatedly misled her or violated ethical requirements. The BBC reported that an independent special master would assist her.123
The Justice Department accused Reyes of exceeding her authority and disparaging government lawyers, according to the Guardian. Reyes denied the department’s request that she withdraw from the case. The redevelopment lawsuit remains ongoing.1
Why it matters
For European readers, the dispute concerns a Washington public park that Trump says could host international golf events, including the Ryder Cup. It also concerns the legal limits on the administration’s ability to close public parkland while pursuing redevelopment.123
Related stories
Version history
- version 1 ·



