World · United States of America
US Supreme Court Allows Trump to Resume Third-Country Deportations
The court's order permits the administration to keep sending migrants to nations besides their homeland as the case works its way through the legal system, a step three liberal justices opposed.
Listen to the story
Short version
The Supreme Court let the Trump administration resume deporting migrants to third countries while litigation continues, as Democratic lawmakers criticize the move and a separate appeals court weighs a contempt probe into earlier deportation flights.
- Ruling issued September 29, 2026; oral arguments set for December
- More than 25,000 migrants deported to roughly 29-35 countries
- D.C. Circuit weighs contempt probe into 2025 CECOT deportation flights
- Democrats Frankel, Menendez call ruling indefensible, urge Congress to act
- First Circuit found 24-hour notice period legally inadequate
Infographic
What's new
- Supreme Court lifted a lower-court order blocking third-country deportations
- DHS General Counsel James Percival hailed the ruling as a second Supreme Court win in a week
- Full D.C. Circuit heard arguments on a separate contempt probe into 2025 CECOT deportation flights
- Democratic Reps. Lois Frankel and Rob Menendez called the ruling indefensible, urging Congress to act
- First Circuit's Sept. 18 ruling found DHS's roughly 24-hour notice period legally inadequate
- Oral arguments on the underlying policy set for December
On September 29, 2026, the country's top court gave the green light for the Trump administration to resume sending migrants to countries other than their homeland as litigation continues, a move that drew opposition from Justices Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson, with the case itself scheduled for argument in December.1345
Infographic
The order
The Supreme Court's order, described as apparently 6-3 in favor of the administration, lifts a lower-court requirement that migrants be given effective notice and a meaningful opportunity to argue they risk persecution before being sent to a third country. The three liberal justices dissented, indicating they would have denied what the administration was asking for.64
Solicitor General John Sauer told the court that lower-court restrictions had "created substantial logistical problems with removals." The administration argued that third-country deportation is an essential tool for removing certain aliens, including those with criminal records, and separately said allowing removals most urgent – including people convicted of murder, rape and kidnapping – would otherwise be delayed.49
Lawyers for the migrants countered that the order does not stop third-country removals altogether but requires the government to carry them out lawfully. They argued that this approach disregarded the serious damage caused when large numbers of long-term U.S. residents, most without any criminal record, are sent to countries other than their own."97
DHS General Counsel James Percival celebrated the ruling as the administration's second Supreme Court win in a week, saying the policy was "back in effect" and urging people in the country illegally to self-deport. Trina Realmuto of the National Immigration Litigation Alliance disputed the administration's framing, saying the First Circuit had already held that the government could not evade persecution and torture protections by simply changing a deportee's destination.51615
Policy by the numbers
Data gathered by France 24 shows that over 25,000 individuals have been removed to nations other than their own since Trump began his term in January 2025, with about 20,000 of those sent to Mexico. At least 5,447 people had been deported by flight to third countries as of August 31, 2026, with 28 countries on six continents having received deportees by that date.2
Thirteen African nations have signed third-country deportation agreements with the United States, and 12 of the 13 had received deportees by August 31, 2026, totalling about 450 people, according to France 24. Ghana alone has received more than 100 deportees. The Hindu similarly noted that around 25,000 individuals have been sent by the administration to upward of two dozen nations under confidential arrangements, most of them to Mexico.26
Washington has committed upward of $81 million across 13 countries tied to these removal arrangements, including over $15 million apiece to Guatemala and Honduras and more than $5 million each to six additional nations. The US also lifted five-year visa restrictions on Ghana following its deportation agreement.2
Accounts of the program's scope vary: Al Jazeera and a tracker called Third Country Deportation Watch put the number of countries with deportation agreements at 29 or more, while other reporting cites at least 35, a discrepancy the dossier does not resolve. The same tracker separately reported at least $49 million in direct US funding tied to the arrangements, though it is unclear whether this figure is separate from or part of the $81 million in commitments reported elsewhere.38152
Legal history
President Trump signed an executive order in January 2025 directing the Department of Homeland Security to remove noncitizens, followed by internal DHS guidance the same month and further procedural guidance in February 2025. Four immigrants filed a federal court challenge in March 2026, and Boston-based District Judge Brian Murphy issued an order barring third-country deportations without notice and an opportunity to challenge them.7
The Supreme Court first paused Murphy's order in May 2025 after Sauer's request, granting the pause on June 23, 2026, with three justices dissenting. After Sauer sought clarification the following day about deporting eight men to South Sudan, the court issued an opinion on July 3, 2026, confirming the pause applied fully to those removals. Murphy issued a final judgment in February 2026 striking down the policy, which the 1st US Circuit Court of Appeals largely upheld on September 18, 2026, restricting but not outright banning third-country removals. The Supreme Court paused Murphy's order again on September 29, 2026, and scheduled oral arguments for December.7410
The First Circuit's September 18 ruling specifically found that DHS guidance giving migrants only about 24 hours' notice before a third-country removal was inadequate for them to meaningfully raise fears of persecution or torture. The appeals court vacated two declarations concerning DHS's obligations regarding destination countries, ruling the plaintiffs lacked standing on those points, and sent remaining questions about the judgment's scope back to the district court. Separately, the Solicitor General told the justices that the lower-court restrictions had already forced DHS to cancel a flight intended to carry 70 migrants to three countries.1516
Human impact
According to the dossier, deportees have been beaten, sexually assaulted, detained or disappeared, with children, women and people with disabilities described as facing the gravest risk. Some migrants have reportedly been imprisoned in unfamiliar countries with serious safety concerns, and many deported have no criminal convictions despite facing risk of torture or persecution, according to The Hindu. Over 250 men have reportedly been confined in a maximum-security facility in El Salvador where conditions have been characterized as inhumane.4162
Rabbiatu Kuyateh, detained during a routine ICE appointment in Baltimore in July 2025, was told after four months in detention that she would be deported to Ghana. "I've known it as my home," she said of the United States. "I worked hard, I paid my taxes," she added, and asked, "Ghana? I don't have any connection to Ghana, so what would I even do there?"2
A group of over a dozen UN human rights experts issued a call for the policy to be stopped, while CBC noted instances in which third countries had unlawfully sent deportees back to the very home nations from which the US had granted them protection. South Sudan, one of the nations receiving deportees under this policy, is a place the US State Department advises citizens not to travel to because of crime, kidnapping and armed conflict.1
Reactions
DHS's Percival framed the ruling as vindication of the administration's approach, saying, "If you claim fear in your home country, DHS has the right to send you elsewhere." Trina Realmuto of the National Immigration Litigation Alliance countered that the First Circuit had already established that the government could not sidestep persecution and torture protections merely by altering a deportee's destination.15
The Human Rights Research Center praised the First Circuit for demanding "meaningful procedures before removal of detainees" and called on DHS to make sure that switching removal destinations doesn't put people in danger of persecution, torture or being sent onward to unsafe places.15
Related contempt investigation
In a related but distinct legal matter stemming from earlier deportations, all the judges of the Washington-based federal appeals court spent three hours on September 29, 2026, weighing whether District Judge James Boasberg can keep probing whether the administration defied his order during a set of 2025 deportation flights.9
The dispute traces to March 15, 2025, when Boasberg issued a temporary restraining order barring deportation of Venezuelan migrants to El Salvador's CECOT prison. Despite the order, two planes carrying affected migrants took off for El Salvador, prompting Boasberg to orally instruct that the flights be brought back; the administration maintains it did not breach the order under the most reasonable reading of it, with officials attributing the transfer decision to then-DHS Secretary Kristi Noem.9
The ACLU said migrants were held in "barbaric conditions" at CECOT for four months, including beatings and being shot with rubber bullets by guards. Trump demanded that Boasberg be impeached, and the Justice Department lodged a misconduct complaint against the judge, though Chief Justice John Roberts openly pushed back against the impeachment push. A D.C. Circuit panel ruled in April that Boasberg must end his contempt investigation, though the full appeals court appeared skeptical of the government's position during the September 29 arguments.9
Why it matters
The case will establish how far a government may go in removing people to nations they have no connection to, and what legal safeguards apply when someone claims they face torture or persecution. For European readers, the ruling is relevant to ongoing debates over third-country return arrangements and the human-rights safeguards attached to them.21
Videos
Related stories
Version history
- version 3 · Added coverage of the separate D.C. Circuit contempt investigation into 2025 CECOT deportation flights and Democratic lawmakers' criticism of the Supreme Court's ruling.
- version 2 · Added DHS's and advocates' reactions to the ruling, specific First Circuit due-process findings, and disputed figures on the number of countries and funding involved.
- version 1 ·



